For the third bullet in Section 3.1, we have:

   *  Limited reputation deployment:Even early deployers that validated
      ARC chains did not deploy robust, dynamic reputation.  Instead,
      they implemented “allow lists” of intermediaries whose ARC
      assertions were always (or mostly) accepted.  This provided
      utility in specific bilateral or consortium relationships but did
      not scale to the open Internet.

Again, this does not specify that the allowlisted domain has to remain at or above the oldest-pass value. Trusting assertions that precede modifications by third parties can be dangerous —an obvious but often overlooked point.

This use case is presented negatively, although it sounds like a legitimate and useful allowlisting method. If static allowlisting is to be criticized, the criteria for dynamic allowlisting should be made explicit.


Best
Ale
--




_______________________________________________
dmarc mailing list -- [email protected]
To unsubscribe send an email to [email protected]

Reply via email to