Anthony,
That's fine.
Regards,
BrianOn 1/30/14 1:46 PM, h chan wrote: > The reason for this requirement is that in some existing mobility > management deployment, in order to support those applications that > does need network-layer mobility support, the mobile host uses HoA so > that all the applications must use the HoA. Then it does not make it > possible for an application to not use HoA. > > So the bottom line in this revision is that the DMM solution only > allows the possibility of not using the network-layer mobility > support. > > How to make use of this possibility is now not a part of this > requirement. Therefore the requirement should avoid implication of > such mechanisms. > > When we called "when needed", there may be implication of a mechanism > to determine/convey the need. > > When we call it "invoke", there may be implication of a mechanism to > invoke. > > Let me try the following: > > REQ2: Bypassable Network-layer mobility support > > DMM solutions MUST enable network-layer mobility but it MUST be > possible to bypass it. > > (plus other sentences on the need and the no need to serve as > explanations only to justify the above) > > H Anthony Chan > > > -----Original Message----- From: Brian Haberman > [mailto:[email protected]] Sent: Thursday, January 30, 2014 > 8:02 AM To: h chan; [email protected] Subject: Re: [DMM] AD Evaluation: > draft-ietf-dmm-requirements > > Hi Anthony, > > On 1/29/14 1:51 PM, h chan wrote: >> Brian, >> >> The requirement is intended to include a capability of not using >> network-layer mobility management, as opposed to using it by >> default. >> >> >> I think it is sufficient to leave to the explanation (the sentences >> after the first sentence) to say that network-layer mobility >> support is not always needed in order to justify this capability. >> >> The alternative then is to say that network-layer mobility is >> provided but it is possible to not use such support. >> >> REQ2: Using and not Using Network-layer mobility support >> >> DMM solutions MUST enable network-layer mobility but it MUST be >> possible to not invoke it. Mobility support is needed, for example, >> when an application or a host cannot cope with a change in the IP >> address when a node moves. Yet a mobile node can often be >> stationary, and mobility support can also be provided at other >> layers. It is then not always necessary to maintain a stable IP >> address or prefix. >> >> Of cause "enable" does not mean it must be used. Yet explicitly say >> "it is possible to not invoke it" is to draw the contrast to using >> it by default. > > My only concern is that it is unclear *who* invokes the network-layer > mobility support. Is it envisioned that the application can signal > the need for mobility support? Does the user have to configure which > applications get support? > > Regards, Brian >
signature.asc
Description: OpenPGP digital signature
_______________________________________________ dmm mailing list [email protected] https://www.ietf.org/mailman/listinfo/dmm
