Dear Mike.

Mike Bird - 01.04.19, 22:52:
> On Mon April 1 2019 13:25:15 Martin Steigerwald wrote:
> > 1) please give any requests for removing one of the core members
> > from the project or using legal enforcement a rest. KatolaZ
> > apologized already several times. So please let it go.
> 
> I have not threatened "legal enforcement" against Devuan.  However
> those of us who use Devuan in production cannot continue to do so
> if Devuan does not take this issue seriously, least we suffer legal
> consequences ourselves.

1) KatolaZ publicly apologized.

2) He wrote that he will make sure not to make such a mistake again.

3) He wrote that no one unauthorized had access to the infrastructure.

4) Devuan is a community project. If you use Devuan in production you 
very likely do it without any support contract with the Devuan team 
whatsoever. Of course that is no license for Devuan people to do bad 
"jokes" like this, but it does also limit what you are entitled to 
request from Devuan people.

5) Apt also has some safe guards.

In what way is that not good enough for you? What would be required for 
you to forgive a mistake and go on with your life?

For me there is a point to just let it go… and for me this point is 
reached here.

If you like a confirmation that it was just a joke by other core Devuan 
core people, I am quite sure that this could be arranged. Maybe other 
Devuan core people could reply to "devuan.org is back" thread, again 
signed via GPG, confirming that it was "just" a joke.

For me the signed mail by KatolaZ is enough. I had contact with KatolaZ 
already, for example when helping to kickstart cooperation between 
Devuan and Debian (debian-init-diversity). I trust him and I see no gain 
whatsoever in removing one of the core Devuan people and contributors 
from the team for a single mistake like this. I trust that he did not 
intend to cause any harm with that "joke".

So, please, is there anything else than removing a member or taking 
legal action against one that could be enough for you to regain trust in 
Devuan again?

I can perfectly understand when other Devuan core people decide not to 
follow your request for such drastic measures. And I'd actually support 
them regarding such a decision.

Remember, if you do not regain trust, you can always also use a different 
distribution. While I actually indeed postponed an update of one of my 
Devuan servers, I trust KatolaZ and just ran the update a few minutes 
ago.

Thanks,
-- 
Martin


_______________________________________________
Dng mailing list
Dng@lists.dyne.org
https://mailinglists.dyne.org/cgi-bin/mailman/listinfo/dng

Reply via email to