Michael Rack wrote:
correct. ppp is a point to point interface and can not assigned to a ethernet-bridge.

But ppp-server have to serve ip-adresses without a dhcp-server?!? you have to manage the dynamic ip-adresses by your ppp-server.

The whole point of what I'm trying to do is *not* doing that. I want all IP 
addresses to be managed in a single place, which is dnsmasq. The reason is that 
it also provides DNS service. If pppd were assigning IP addresses itself, the 
DNS server would be unaware of that. Moreover, the auto-configuration 
possibilities of PPP are inferior compared to DHCP.

What server is running on your machine?

What kind of server do you mean? If you are asking about the PPP server, it's 
the classic pppd from http://ppp.samba.org/.

You use a dhcpc-plugin, this plugin have to relay all broadcast messages to dnsmasq. I think the problem is located on your dhcpc-plugin.

The plugin can't relay anything. It seems you misunderstood the purpose of it. 
The plugin is not involved in the communication with the PPP peers in any way 
at all. When pppd needs an IP address to assign to a peer it asks the plugin. 
The plugin performes DHCP negotiation with dnsmasq while the rest of pppd is 
waiting (completely unaware of that fact). When the plugin gets an IP address 
it returns it to pppd and the configuration of the PPP link continues. After 
that the plugin remains idle, since its job has been done. The subsequent 
DHCPINFORM messages come from the peer via the PPP link, so as far as pppd is 
concerned, those are just normal traffic.

Kind regards,
Sergei.


Am 17.10.2009 20:18, schrieb Sergei Zhirikov:
Michael Rack wrote:
You have to setup a bridge on your linux-router and assign every dynamic
created ppp-interface to that.

        brctl addif br0 pppx

Configure DNSMASQ to listen on the bridges interface.

        interface=br0
        bind-interfaces

And well, you're done.

Cheers,
Michael.
Thanks for the suggestion, Michael.

I have tried it, but unfortunately it doesn't work :(.
The command "brctl addif br0 ppp0" fails with "can't add ppp0 to bridge br0: Invalid 
argument". It looks like point-to-point interfaces can not be added to a bridge (I tried also 
with a TUN device, just to see if it could be added, and got the same error message).
--
Kind regards,
Sergei.


Am 17.10.2009 14:04, schrieb Sergei Zhirikov:
Hi,

I'm using dnsmasq as a DHCP and DNS server on my Linux home gateway, which is 
also a IPSec/L2TP VPN server. For IP address allocation for the VPN PPP tunnels 
I use ppp-dhcpc plugin, which pretends to be a DHCP relay and requests IP 
addresses from dnsmasq. That part works fine.

However, when the PPP link has been established the VPN client (a Windows PC in 
my case, but I don't think it's relevant) send DHCPINFORM request to the 
broadcast address 255.255.255.255. That request reaches the Linux gateway via 
the PPP link, but dnsmasq does not reply, because it can see that the request 
is coming from an interface it is not configured to serve.

I would really like dnsmasq to reply to those DHCPINFORM requests coming in 
through the PPP links, but I haven't been able to configure dnsmasq for that. I 
can't tell it to serve the PPP interface, because the interface name is 
assigned dynamically (thus not known in advance). I can not tell dnsmasq to 
serve all interfaces with some exceptions either, because then the list of the 
exceptions would have to contain dynamically assigned names.

I have tried some tricks with iptables. Tried to use "-j ROUTE --iif ifname" to 
make the packets appear coming form another interface with a fixed name that dnsmasq is 
configured to serve, but dnsmasq still does not reply as if it somehow can see the 
original interface name.

I have tried to use a pair of VETH interfaces to route the incoming packets to 
one end of the virtual tunnel so that they would appear to dnsmasq coming out 
of the other end, but that didn't work, because I didn't manage to get the 
routing work the way I wanted (perhaps, because I lack necessary knowledge 
about advanced routing).

I would appreciate any kind of help with this problem.

Thank you,
Kind regards,

Sergei.


_______________________________________________
Dnsmasq-discuss mailing list
[email protected]
http://lists.thekelleys.org.uk/mailman/listinfo/dnsmasq-discuss

_______________________________________________
Dnsmasq-discuss mailing list
[email protected]
http://lists.thekelleys.org.uk/mailman/listinfo/dnsmasq-discuss


Reply via email to