> On 2 Nov 2026, at 16:20, Bob Hinden <[email protected]> wrote:
> 
> Nice to see a short charter!

Thanks Bob. Let's keep it that way. :-)

>> The IESG will decide whenever some aspects of DNS protocol activities are 
>> best carried out in other WGs. When this happens, those topics will be out 
>> of scope for the name-to-be-decided WG.
> 
> Strongly suggest this be left to the relevant ADs and w.g. chairs.   Not 
> everything needs a full IESG decision.   

I think this is nit-picking. Sometimes these decisions could be for the ADs & 
co-chairs, sometimes they won't. The IESG is ultimately responsible for taking 
these decisions or delegating them to the appropriate AD(s) and/or WG 
co-chairs(s). We shouldn't need to spell this out in the WG charter.

> Who are "other appropriate organizations” mean?  Citing some examples would 
> be good.

I had in mind the likes of ICANN, DNS-OARC, CENTR and the DNS-related WGs in 
RIR-land. There are sure to be others. Compiling these sorts of shopping lists 
and adding them to a charter is a bad idea IMO. Updating a shopping list will 
mean rewriting the WG charter. Let's not go down that rathole.

_______________________________________________
DNSOP mailing list -- [email protected]
To unsubscribe send an email to [email protected]

Reply via email to