Hoi Paul,

On 7 Nov 2026, at 06:57, Paul Wouters <[email protected]> wrote:

> This seems fine, but it should probably also clarify where RRSIG RRs go for 
> those CNAMEs. 

The case we were reacting to (and trying to prevent recurrence of) was a 
response supplied to stub resolvers that had critical expectations about the 
ordering of records in the answer section. 

The cases we know about come from a long tail of legacy devices that might 
never be upgraded, hence trying to do something about it in the spec. But I 
don't think we see such devices send queries with DO=1. We can check, of 
course. But it feels like many of these cases might even pre-date DNSSEC.

If there are no known negative consequences of existing practices regarding 
RRSIG packing in the answer section, it feels like it would be over-specifying 
to require something new?

> Or possibly, in general, especially if the goal is that a resolver can read 
> top down while , reading, validating and adding to its cache.

This seems like a broader mandate than this draft has, if I recall earlier 
conversations about it correctly. 


Joe
_______________________________________________
DNSOP mailing list -- [email protected]
To unsubscribe send an email to [email protected]

Reply via email to