It appears that Paul Wouters  <[email protected]> said:
>If I understood it correctly, there are multiple solution in both
>documents:
>
>1) use DNS to AXFR the root zone, pretending this is a hidden primary 
>configuration.
>2) download the zone over HTTPS (or external AXFR?) and feed it into the 
>resolver cold cache.
>
>Where 1) runs as kind of as authoritative and 2) runs as recursive

I think the issues of how you get the root zone and what you do with it are
separate.  

>For DNS servers supporting running auth+recursive, 1) might be the best
>solution. For DNS servers not supporting auth but only recursive, 2)
>might be the best solution.

There's a lot of fuzz between the two.  For example I use unbound which is 
mostly
a recursive server but can also be configured as auth for specific zones,
which can be fetched by AXFR or HTTP, either with or without TLS.

>I would say merge these two into one document to prevent the duplication
>of lots of text and explain both as valid implementation strategies.

Agreed.

R's,
John
_______________________________________________
DNSOP mailing list -- [email protected]
To unsubscribe send an email to [email protected]

Reply via email to