Steve, Since I will be teaching Reynolds v Sims in my election law class in 2 weeks, I would be interested in your ideas on the "seemingly glaring logical errors made by the Supreme Court in the Reynolds v Sims (1964) decision." I have my own ideas about the problems in that case. Edward Still Lawyer, Birmingham AL USA Chairman, Center for Voting and Democracy, Washington DC Adjunct Professor of Law, University of Alabama, Tuscaloosa