I assume this is from Colorado, and have no idea who else has seen it.

I see it as worth considering the thinking, although I AM NOT signing on as backing any of it.

On Jul 23, 2011, at 11:32 PM, Dave Ketchum wrote:

Knowing of IRV and Condorcet methods of counting ballots, the first paragraph below makes me wonder how valid the the author's claims may be. The very last few lines help.
.     STV - not used here - THANKS
. Condorcet - also not used here - think more whether this is better.

On Jul 23, 2011, at 3:59 PM, preferentiality wrote:

Ranked Ballot (voters ranking candidates in order of preference) will
give us (PRACTICABLE!) Instant TRUE Democracy for ALL the World, &
even put an end to all war forever.

Because it gives an equal chance of winning to not just all parties,
but all combinations of programs, “RB” is the only thing that’s truly
both just & free. Because it always elects the candidate most exactly
in the middle of all voting, RB is top-dead-center counter extremist,
& thus more anti-terrorist than all the many recent retrenchments
combined & thus will even disallow the tendency of (virtually two-
party) parliamentary systems to give the top to the biggest gang on
the block, sometimes with violently extremist results.

Worth reading more - I am not buying the author's claims of achieving perfection. There are many topics for which more than two possible choices seem worth debating possible value.

Dave Ketchum

RB is the sole unchangeable plank & bylaw of a Ranked Ballot Party,
the only practicable third party.)  We imagine running on the single
issue of RB, promising a citizens’ advisory board based on Organized
Communications, “OC”, small randomly assigned discussion groups
electing reps to higher & higher randomly assigned levels, by means of
RB, ‘til one small group, most exactly in the middle of all voting,
remains at the top, to guide us in the rest, which group by its merest
invitation to speak  inevitably names the perfect compromise & next
winner That’s the instant part. You do the same, from the most local
on up.
By the power of its example alone, RB will give us practicable instant
worldwide true democracy.  Virtually no democracy has ever been
attacked by another.  In a world of only democracies, there would no
longer be need of the counter-productive wastefulness of armies, war
or the preparation for war.  RB will bring us that & all else: a real
solution to terror, a perfect marriage of Freedom & Justice, Tradition
& Modernity, Palestinian & Jew, Free Market & Communalism, all the
fairness, payback & make-up one could wish for, clean back to the Cro-
Magnons, ecologically sustainable politics, what’s best for all
workers, instant global women’s liberation, world-wide luxury, a
rationalization of the drug wars, human unity, the Freedom of Justice
& the Justice of Freedom, perhaps the only possible solution to the
world’s only real problem, the Israeli/Palestinian conflict (once they both are made to have to adopt RB), even integrity. RB is to the horse
& buggy two-party system as shopping in the Mall of America is to
shopping in Soviet Russia.  The majority of the problems we face are
due to the heavy-footedness of the two party system.  RB lessens the
power of the extremes, whether authoritarian, economic or sectarian,
except through what they can gain by persuasion, which is only what’s
just.  While it would be equally useful for all else, RB’s real power
is perhaps most clearly shown in the case of Iraq.  Unless its
Parliament comes to select the Prime Minister by means of RB, it may
not hold & the country, region & world will be in danger of going to
war over some ancient grudge, oil well, multi-ethnic city, or
sabotaged pipeline.  While the new constitution does call for the
selection of the President by a 2/3 vote in the first round (even if
only by the parliament & not the people) (who may then decide who will
form the new government) & then by a run-off between the top two vote
getters in the second round, if that fails to move all three tribes to
nominate centrists, then the resulting handful of old men in a back
room will fall far short of RB’s ultimate retail politics.  RB would
be equally useful for all electoral systems (parliamentary or
presidential, the parliaments choosing their PMs by RB from among
their members, lest they produce another Hitler or other extreme)
coops, collective leaderships, tribal groupings, religious
confessions, political parties, associations or, even cabals. Whoever
gets there first wins.  For leaders to best represent their country,
or district, whether chosen at large or by a representative body, they
must be the perfect compromise, most exactly in the middle, as is
given by RB.  Yet because it gives minorities a real say in which
member of the plurality/majority gets chosen, RB is the only thing
that will lead Iraqis, or anyone else, to support any plan more than
inadequate confederation.   It will result in “phantasmagoric
subtlefaction”, real-time alternatives to all proposals, from
wherever: market, coop or social, or tribal, theological or universal,
answering infinitely more questions at a time than the two party
system’s “who is least bad”. Both more Liberty & Justice can be found
in RB than in any ideology.  With brakes & reverse comes no more need
to suppress popular movements around the world.  RB will give us
subtlety, responsivity, light-footedness, long-sightedness,
objectivity, economy, unity, accountability, integrity & victory over
extremism. Palestinians & Jews will give up fighting over a sliver of
desert & become members of global cooperatives, all the various forms
of hegemonism, whether up front, subterranean or unconscious, will be
given up, in exchange for leading the world to the light, & America
will finally realize the need for an adequate, howsoever minimal,
safety net as the price & foundation of a free market.
Help put this idea, in time, to as many as possible, before “Clockwork
Orange” (overpopulation), “1984” (high-tech dictatorship), cosmic
collision, tectonic, economic or environmental collapse, or literalist
or criminal contretemps.  The cost of a full page national ad
(sufficient to put RB to virtually all the world) would be repaid in
no time, once all that money gets put to actual productive use, at
pre-9/11 US annual defense spending of $10,000 per family. Ten to the
power of ten (ten levels of groups of ten) would be sufficient to
organize & unite all mankind.
RB is very freeing.  Because it always chooses the candidate in the
middle, all who support it are perfectly top-dead-center, with no more
need to fear self expression.  Politics will become a family
discussion around the kitchen table, with no more jumping back & forth
between extremes, or absence of the economists’ requirement of
predictability for growth.  All that’s needed is to let go of the nut
& get your fist back out of the knothole, to free yourself, & to rest
in the knowledge that RB will give us perfect Freedom & perfect
Justice, at one & the same time, even if not necessarily in the form
imagined, as if anyone would then care.  For instance, no woman ever
got pregnant to have an abortion, but RB will make the point moot.
Good enough for New Zealand, Australia, Kerala India, Iraq, London,
Ireland, Cambridge Mass, Burlington & 95% of the townships of Vermont,
Pierce County Washington, St Paul & Minneapolis Minnesota, the Utah
Republican Party for the selection of statewide candidates, the
platforms of both the Green & Libertarian Parties & 50 college student
bodies across the US with more places coming every year, but not good
enough for the rest of us?  It must be in somebody’s interest!  How
can any wish it of others if they do not have it themselves?  Having
spent every spare moment from the invasion, to the vote on the
constitution emailing every Iraqi we could find about RB, we would
like to claim some little credit for the reforms they did adopt.  The
only imaginable definition of Freedom (& Morality) is “Do as you wish,
but harm no other”.  The maker & sustainer of this world (& cosmos!)
could have no need of one bit of it. The fiercer the history of the
planet, the sooner it would have been blissed out behind ethnic
homogeneity, & thus democracy.  Tax consumption, not investment, &
spread the productivity around.  All powers to their lowest
appropriate level.  All human evil is due to the out of phase
fluctuation of population & food supply, so no-one alive is
responsible for the mess we find ourselves in, except for what they do
now.   Justice is the redress of past violence, Freedom the current
absence of violence & Nonviolence the only basis of all Morality.
Just go out & collect signatures, asking those who sign to collect
them for you as well. The more the merrier. (The “additive” form of
RB is to count the first choices & if no-one has 50%, to add in the
next choices, & so on until someone finally does.)  “Consider that
which is common in the sight of all men.”
--


----
Election-Methods mailing list - see http://electorama.com/em for list info

Reply via email to