On Aug 14, 2007, at 12:30 AM, Mark James wrote:

Entourage is the only one that properly imports emailer. But it sucks. A
huge bummer is no random signatures. I have been traveling, but will
probably be trying MailSmith next, I am going to import Emailer "through"
entourage" and see how Mailsmith works for my work style. Entourage is
hard to get used to, and not very efficient.

I may have worked on this issue with you already, so forgive me if this is a repeat.

Did you try exporting your Mail email as mbox files? From there you can use Mail.app's Import Mailboxes, selecting "other" as the type and import the mbox files into Mail.

I know I worked on this with someone, and they had issue with the first line of the Mbox file as exported by Emailer, containing an incorrect date. I looked into that (but don't think I gave them the heads up) and I think (but could very well be entirely wrong) that the first line in these cases is supposed to carry some unique mail ID strings, and that out of the context of a mail server, that first line no longer serves a purpose. So that incorrect date should be safe to ignore as I don't think that first line is going to be paid attention to anyway.

The mbox format is supposed to start the email with From_ (From followed by a space character), and continue until the next From_ or until the end of the file. So that first line containing nothing more than invalid data should be ignored by the utility that is used to read back in the mbox file (Mail.app in this case). I believe Eudora's mbox format did something similar by putting some info into the first line of the file.


Of course, I could be remembering the issue wrong, and the incorrect date wasn't in the first line, but rather was in the date contained in the mbox header From_ line. In which case, that *might* cause a problem if that date is referenced in any way during import. However, it may not be as the email headers should still contain the correct email date strings, and Mail.app (or whatever is doing the importing) may refer to those lines for the message date info.

In other words, I'd give it a whirl and see what happens before nixing it as a possible way to import Emailer mail into Mail.app without access to Classic (since Mail.app requires starting Emailer to do the import, thus anyone on an Intel machine would not be able to do the import).

Of course, the Export to mbox from Emailer may be more tedious then it is worth if you have too many folders to deal with. If that is the issue, then I'd look at whatever that email archiving tool is that others here have reported using (not eMessageArchiver, although in theory that could be made to work as well, you could import everything into eMA, and then add a new calculated field that will create a correct mbox version of the message, and then use FMP's ability to export data to dump out said field of all records). I seem to have a mental blank on what that other app's name is. I know it is shareware for $25 or something like that.

-chris
<www.mythtech.net>


___________________________________________________________________________
To unsubscribe send a mail message with a SUBJECT line of "unsubscribe" to
<[EMAIL PROTECTED]>  or  <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>

Reply via email to