Hi Terry, I appreciate the perspective you bring to this discussion. Just to be clear, by no means do I credit swimsuit technology for all the gains made in swimming over the past several decades. As you have pointed out, there have been numerous advances in everything from coaching, training, technique, nutrition, swimsuits, right down to the pools themselves. You are also correct in pointing out that there has been a progressive improvement in world record times. Indeed, the improvement in world record times has followed a fairly predictable exponential curve, which makes sense, because knowledge increases and technology improves at an exponential rate. HOWEVER, the 2008 Olympics is distinct because of the fact that it represented a huge break from this previous and predictable rate of improvement. You can read the study and statistical breakdown (by the Counsilman Center) right here: http://65.110.72.225/SPIPDF/120908SwimperformancesIU2008C.pdf This is a fascinating and very readable document.
What it points out, among many things, is that the number of records broken in this last (2008) Olympic year exceed that of the best previous Olympic years by nearly 100% - a definite anomaly from the previously uniform trend. There are some fairly clear correlations that can be drawn to the use (or non-use) of body suits during the months leading up to the Olympics, and during the Olympics themselves. Especially interesting is the "Japan Experiment", where their top swimmers swam their events first without and then without the suits, and were found to be, on average, 1.06% faster when wearing the suits. This amounted, for example, to a 1.5 second improvement in Katijima's best previous 200 breaststroke time - that's huge. Also interesting is the fact that the suits were found to be most beneficial in short- distance sprint events, and less so for long distance endurance swims. I don't know if there is any published scientific proof of the effectiveness of the body suits, but intuitively, when you cover the human body in a material modeled after shark skin, and you stiffen it through the use of compression, it's going to affect how it behaves in the water in a positive manner. I recognize that the question of whether the effects of the suits is mechanical or psychological is still open to some dispute, but the fact that they do produce a positive effect is pretty clear. For $600, I would hope so. As I've said, to me, all this is just noise. I understand the economic realities of sports. I understand that world records = hype = more money for everyone involved. I understand the futility behind trying to stop the inexorable march of progress, and am not suggesting that would be a good thing. I'm not even trying to convince anyone of which way they should go, or which way the sport should go - that's for people a lot smarter and more invested in swimming than myself to decide. On a level, I would like it if we could maintain the "purity" of the sport and truly have it be about the best performance by the best athlete, but recognize that this is a pipe dream; there is no parity and no purity and there never has been. I'm simply making a personal choice because for myself, I don't see the point. What I care about is the IMPROVEMENT in my times, not my absolute times, which aren't competitive in my age group anyway. To me, there's no thrill in improving my 200 fly time by 10 seconds, knowing that it's only because of a technology that I'm wearing, even if it is FINA-approved. And it doesn't make economic sense for me to spend $600 on a swimsuit to improve my 200 fly time by 10 seconds when the top competitors in my age group are beating me by a minute-and-a- half. Other swimmers may find meaning or joy in swimming the absolute fastest possible time they can by any legal means, and that's fine too. On Dec 15, 12:16 am, "Terry" <[email protected]> wrote: > Brad, > I just deleted a long response I had written about technology instead I am > going to keep it short. > Look at the times from the 1972 Olympics and then look at the times from the > 1976 Olympics the records dropped about 2 seconds per 100 in almost every > event even more in the longer ones 10 seconds in the 400 free, 50 seconds in > the 1500 and the main new technology change was training and better > athletes, but swim suits had also changed to Lycra suits and we put on a > "Pan" like teflon spray called "Time Off". Now look at the times from 2004 > with this years and again we see a lot of new world records but by fractions > of seconds per 100 not the 2 plus seconds of 1976. And look at the swimmers > this year, just look at pictures of Michael Philips then and now what do we > see, 2004 a tall skinny kid and now- a tall buffed man, the same can be said > for the women just look at someone like Dara Torres, would we have seen > someone built like her 4, 8 or in her case 24 years ago? NO! So what has > really changed again just like in 1976 is TRAINING and BETTER ATHLETES. > Reguardless of how much Speedo spins it (yes the compression and all the > rest may give me the psychologcal feeling that I can swim faster, I know > that after I spend $600 on a suit it better make me faster and if I believe > it and I also know I have TRAINED right I will swim faster) if I haven't > trained right even with the LZR I am not going to swim any faster. >
