Hello from San Diego:


At the urging of a colleague, I looked further into the question
raised by Mike Rains, whether or not a power supply needs to be
in a fire enclosure.

(I had stated that all primary circuits required a fire enclosure.)

In IEC 950 and its clones, Sub-clause 4.4.1 specifies two methods 
for "achieving resistance to fire."
     
    Method 1:  Construction as specified in Sub-clause 4.4.2 
               and 4.4.3.
     
    Method 2:  Fault tests as specified in Sub-clause 5.4.6,
               third dashed paragraph.
     
Sub-clause 5.4.6 first dashed paragraph requires fault tests in 
any components in primary circuits -- REGARDLESS whether the 
primary circuit is in a fire enclosure or not.  

The third dashed paragraph implies tests in addition to the 
first dashed paragraph, i.e., such as overload.  Compliance with
this paragraph, in addition to the first dashed paragraph,
qualifies a circuit and its components for no fire enclosure.

So, the standard does not require a fire enclosure for a power
supply provided it is tested in accordance with BOTH first and
third dashed paragraphs of Sub-clause 5.4.6.

This is a different reasoning process than that of Mike Rains.


Best regards,
Rich



-------------------------------------------------------------
 Richard Nute                             Quality Department 
 Hewlett-Packard Company           Product Regulations Group 
 San Diego Division (SDD)          Tel   :      619 655 3329 
 16399 West Bernardo Drive         FAX   :      619 655 4979 
 San Diego, California 92127       e-mail:  ri...@sdd.hp.com 
-------------------------------------------------------------


Reply via email to