First I apologise for not contributing to this discussion. I have been travelling and busy since my return. Due to this I have not really been following prior threads closely enough to respond in detail. It is easier for me to start a new thread, accepting that in doing so, in ignorance of other discussions, I risk redundancy.
I understand all art to be intrinsically participatory. That is why, since the early 1980¹s, I have primarily made interactive artworks. My current thinking on this is focused on two things. Firstly, expanded concepts of agency (what or who can be an active participant?) and secondly, but directly emerging from the first question, how creativity and knowledge formation can be regarded as forms of social interaction rather than outcomes of activities. I am not going to address the first question here in any detail as it is not explicitly evoked in Empyre¹s current theme, although I will suggest that Latour¹s concept of actor-network-theory can be seen as a useful platform for understanding interactions between people and things and how these interactions altogether might permit authorship and creativity to emerge as sets of discursive relations rather than outcomes of processes. Here I will focus on creativity as a function of communities and something that brings communities into existence. Specific creative communities can be regarded as microcosms of larger communities. Communities of artists, as with other communities, develop as cultural paradigms crystallise or dissipate. This is a recursive and iterative process involving complex social interactions. Particular creative communities can act as a lens through which social change may be observed. Many contemporary communities exist as both local and global phenomena, in Ocreative cities¹ and Oglobal networks¹, and appear to draw value from this conjunction of opposites. Many current examples from networked culture could be cited here, from large scale communities of dispersed interests (Facebook) to specialist communities with acutely honed interests (Empyre). An insight here is that whilst creativity is often perceived as the product of the individual artist, or creative ensemble, it can also be considered an emergent phenomenon of communities, driving change and facilitating individual or ensemble creativity. The key understanding here is that creativity can be a performative activity (Latour¹s concept of actor-network-theory is useful here) released when engaged through and by a community. In this context the model of the solitary artist, producing artefacts that embody creativity, is contested as the ideal method to achieve creative outcomes. Here creativity is proposed as an activity of exchange that enables (creates) people and communities. Anthropologist James Leach, in his book Creative Land (2003), observes and describes cultural practices where the creation of new things and the ritualised forms of exchange enacted around them function to both ³create² individuals and bind them to social groups, thus ³creating² the community they inhabit. Leach¹s argument is an interesting take on the concept of the gift-economy. Given this understanding, it is possible to conceive of creativity as emergent from and innate to the interactions of people. Such an understanding also combats an instrumentalist view of creativity and novelty, where governments and corporations demand of artists and researchers that their creations and inventions have clear social (read ³economic²) value. In the argument proposed here, creativity is not valued as arising from a perceived need, a solution or product, nor from a supply-side ³blue skies² ideal, but as an emergent property of communities. Marika Luders (³Why and how online sociability became part and parcel of teenage life², Blackwell Handbook of Internet Studies 2009) observes that creativity Ois now commonly understood as part of what constitutes human beings. Moreover, creativity is not necessarily (or even ever) an isolated phenomenon¹. Rob Pope ( Creativity: Theory, History, Practice, Routledge 2005) states Obeing creative is, at least potentially, the natural and normal state of anyone healthy in a sane and stimulating community S realising that potential is as much a matter of collaboration and Oco-creation¹ as of splendid or miserable isolation¹. Thus it can be argued that all communities are potentially creative. In this context we need to ask what ³creativity² is? We can seek to situate it as an activity defined by and defining of communities, seeking to transcend the debate on the instrumentality of creativity and knowledge, situating innovation as an ontological factor in the formation of communities. This approach allows the deconstruction of traditional perceptions of creative activities and the development of a less reductive understanding of creativity and its value. Doing this leads directly to fundamental questions regarding the public value of creativity and the role it plays in creating communities. I would propose the term ontopoeisis to describe these processes. This is the position I am currently trying to develop. I am not sure where it will go at this stage. I am not even sure if my thinking here is reflected in my own artistic practice. It might be, to some degree, in that I involve audiences, spectators and often unwitting passers-by in the generation of material that constitutes the actual artwork and of course I recognise the all-powerful character of the ³reader² who interprets a work into existence. But this is not quite the same thing as what I am seeking to describe above. As an artist who is very much a product of 20th century individualism, acting upon things and acted upon, splendidly unitary in my identity, it is a challenge to understand something as core to the sense of self as creativity in a new way, fundamentally different to how familiar models propose it. As I argue that creativity is a process of becoming, so to is coming to viscerally understand this. Regards Simon Simon Biggs Research Professor edinburgh college of art [email protected] www.eca.ac.uk www.eca.ac.uk/circle/ [email protected] www.littlepig.org.uk AIM/Skype: simonbiggsuk Edinburgh College of Art (eca) is a charity registered in Scotland, number SC009201
_______________________________________________ empyre forum [email protected] http://www.subtle.net/empyre
