From: Richard Rinehart <[email protected]> To: Timothy Murray <[email protected]>, renate ferro <[email protected]> Subject: Fwd: Invitation to Join "Participatory Art: Digital Traces,": -empyre-in June
Empyre Richard Rinehart Participatory Art The early to mid 1990's saw the expansion of the Silicon Valley bubble, the birth of the "Internet" in the mass media ala the Web, and not coincidentally an explosion of net art. Though it was often critical of the bubble and it's attendant hype, net art just as often was not, and in fact was caught up in the same psycho-cultural-linguistic storm. "Interactive media" ruled and the term "interactivity" achieved an absolute positive moral value. Adding "interactivity" to anything made it better, from education to gaming to art and the more interactivity, the better yet. I think this is understandable because interactive media became the latest mirror reflecting of our shared aspirations about democracy simplistically rendered as the most interactive (read: participatory) form of government. There remains some truth to this equation, but more often than not it seemed simplistic and worse, misleading, with numerous examples of the viewer/voter being granted the illusion of agency in both art and politics. "Interactive media" became "interactive art" and this somehow implied a binary state in which any given artwork was, or was not, interactive (in the same way that the cold war mindset held that a government was either wholly democratic and participatory or dictatorial and exclusive.) I've been conflating the terms "interactive" with "participatory" art here, and though one could be said to emphasize media and the other people, I propose that they are actually just relative historical terms for speaking about the same egalitarian aspirations. All artworks are interactive of course, but with regards to media art, we can further define a continuum, rather than binary state, for interactive or participatory art, that might look something like this (going from less to more interactive): A. Linear Navigation (or sit-back-and-watch art) that function like traditional film, such as John Simon's "Every Icon" B. Non-Linear Navigation in which the viewer makes some choice about the unfolding/pacing of the work such as Ben Benjamin's "Superbad" C. Artworks that allow the viewer to change the form of the work, albeit in a temporary, solo manner that snaps back after the browser closes. Eva Hasa's "Henry" comes to mind. D. Artworks that allow the viewer to change the form of the work in a more lasting manner, usually by contributing/adding content, such as Chris Bassett's "Lost Love Project". E. Works that allow one to not only add (ensuring the continuation of the work) but also to take away, reduce, or delete, thus implicating the disappearance of the work, such as Peter Edmund's "Swarm Sketch". F. Lastly, those works that allow the viewer to alter some of the fundamental parameters of the work and thus become more than viewers or even "participants", but rather co-creators. Radical Software Group's "Carnivore" project or Lisa Jevbratt's "LifeLike" project come to mind. Caveats about the above framework. It's not definitive, especially since it also suggest a binary simply stretched out, but I'm suggesting that interactivity or participation are not simply switches that can be turned on or off in any given artwork and this "Rinehart's Ladder of Interactive Art" is simply one way to illustrate that notion. It implies that neither end of the continuum is more virtuous but simply represent different strategies. It further underscores the notion that some level of interactivity is built-into (unconscious) in all artworks in a kind of anti-Friedman statement that holds all artworks are contingent upon the viewer to complete them. On that last point, all artworks in whatever media are inherently interactive, so what, if anything, does new media art bring to this equation? Well, there might actually be a couple of things. Interactivity in art is a useful technique for modeling power relationships through the exchange of agency. New media art certainly adds to the artist's toolkit whole new ways of modeling agency and power, thus expanding the art vocabulary. More specifically new media art seems naturally inclined to do what traditional media art is not; that is to actually record the trace of the viewer's interaction; that is to *remember* each specific interaction and each specific participant and to incorporate that trace for others to view and react to, etc. There are two implications here. One is that the artwork is itself transformed by interaction; interaction can be cumulative over a long term and social rather than solitary and this may change the quality as well as quantity of interaction. Secondly, new media art is good at remembering specific interactions and their authors. Past artworks like Gonzalez-Torres' "Candy Spills" took gallery art to a new level of participation, but even these flattened out "the audience" into one undifferentiated mass whose impacts the artwork remembers like a scar. I think that net art 2.0 (or whatever generation we're in now) is increasingly leaving behind the myth of "interactivity!" and going for more nuanced, focused, or purposefully limited participation in order to form accurate models that are not inflected with automatic value judgments. We're entering the era of post-interactive media art, art that holds the potential to expand our vocabulary for talking about social and power dynamics and to recognize, remember, and build upon individual experiences. Lastly, all of the above leaves it in the hands of the artists, audiences, and artworks to "be interactive" or participatory, but I'd like to suggest in closing that there might be a role for the institutions of art to likewise re-consider notions of participation by taking advantage of some of the unique properties of media art. For instance, the Open Museum is an emergent project at UC Berkeley that would offer access to an open-source archive of media art that allows a kind of access to artworks not possible with physical objects and suggests art can be deployed, en masse, in new ways well beyond our current limited notions of "exhibition" or "research". It remains to be seen how far institutions are willing to go with any particular idea in reality, but they are also implicated in all this participation, surely. Bio: Richard Rinehart is Digital Media Director & Adjunct Curator at the UC Berkeley Art Museum/Pacific Film Archive. Some of his projects and papers can be found at http://www.coyoteyip.com. ---------------------------- Richard Rinehart --------------- Digital Media Director & Adjunct Curator Berkeley Art Museum and Pacific Film Archive bampfa.berkeley.edu --------------- University of California, Berkeley --------------- 2625 Durant Ave. Berkeley, CA, 94720-2250 ph.510.642.5240 fx.510.642.5269 -- Timothy Murray Director, Society for the Humanities http://www.arts.cornell.edu/sochum/ Curator, The Rose Goldsen Archive of New Media Art, Cornell Library http://goldsen.library.cornell.edu Professor of Comparative Literature and English A. D. White House Cornell University Ithaca, New York 14853 _______________________________________________ empyre forum [email protected] http://www.subtle.net/empyre
