jpeg pushed a commit to branch master. http://git.enlightenment.org/core/efl.git/commit/?id=85d04a74d43a6ec2aa5e595284d5d0fdefeb8f77
commit 85d04a74d43a6ec2aa5e595284d5d0fdefeb8f77 Author: Jean-Philippe Andre <jp.an...@samsung.com> Date: Mon Aug 21 18:25:39 2017 +0900 elm_box: Fix support of aspect hints Test scenario: ephoto without a recent patch (47fe2b9ab03c151b0f4). Before any further explanation, ephoto was definitely misusing the aspect API here. A label most definitely shouldn't be sized based on an aspect ratio, that's just crazy (you really want to make it as tall as it's wide?) If a box has an aspected item, it needs to run its min calc loop twice: 1. Once to determine the "true" min size in the direction of the box (ie. in X in case of a horizontal box), and 2. Once more in order to apply the aspect ratio to aspected items and augment the perpendicular min size (ie. Y for horizontal). After that, it can go and layout the items based on the available size. As we may guess from the above description (1) determines min W and (2) determines min H (in horizontal mode). BUT, there were two problems: - The wrong item min size was used inside the 2nd loop (the code was not symmetrical between horizontal and vertical modes). These are the changes in _smart_extents_non_homogeneous_calc. - The box min length was based on the actual size of aspected items, rather than their min size. This goes against the observation. These are the changes in _smart_extents_calculate. Ref T5888 @fix --- src/lib/elementary/els_box.c | 10 +++++++--- 1 file changed, 7 insertions(+), 3 deletions(-) diff --git a/src/lib/elementary/els_box.c b/src/lib/elementary/els_box.c index 199b739cf0..2be92907e2 100644 --- a/src/lib/elementary/els_box.c +++ b/src/lib/elementary/els_box.c @@ -184,7 +184,7 @@ _smart_extents_non_homogeneous_calc(Evas_Object_Box_Data *priv, int w, int h, in if (horizontal) { /* use min size to start */ - ww = *rw; + ww = mnw; if ((expand > 0) && (wx > 0.0)) { /* add remaining container value after applying weight hint */ @@ -195,7 +195,7 @@ _smart_extents_non_homogeneous_calc(Evas_Object_Box_Data *priv, int w, int h, in } else { - hh = *rh; + hh = mnh; if ((expand > 0) && (wy > 0.0)) { oh = ((h - cminh) * wy) / expand; @@ -334,8 +334,12 @@ _smart_extents_calculate(Evas_Object *box, Evas_Object_Box_Data *priv, int w, in /* aspect can only be accurately calculated after the full (non-aspected) min size of the box has * been calculated due to the use of this min size during aspect calculations */ + int aminw = minw; + int aminh = minh; _smart_extents_padding_calc(priv, &minw, &minh, &maxw, &maxh, horizontal); - _smart_extents_non_homogeneous_calc(priv, w, h, &minw, &minh, &maxw, &maxh, expand, horizontal, 1); + _smart_extents_non_homogeneous_calc(priv, w, h, &aminw, &aminh, &maxw, &maxh, expand, horizontal, 1); + if (horizontal) minh = aminh; + else minw = aminw; } } _smart_extents_padding_calc(priv, &minw, &minh, &maxw, &maxh, horizontal); --