> This may
> sound picky, but if you use a 20mm lens on an XL1 and expect to get
> the same thing as a 144mm on your EOS, you will be really surprised.
> The angle of view is truly divided by 7.2 as you expect, but the
> perspective is still that of a 20mm, wide angle distortion and all.
> So don't try to get a good portrait shot with a 20mm on your XL1.
> At least don't ever show that video to the subject :-)
> 
> Jim




You're really wrong here, Jim.  The perspective does not depend on the
focal length of the lens, but on your distance from the subject.  So,
because of this, if you use a 20mm on your 35mm camera and fill the
frame with your subject head, you will be very close to the subject
causing the nose to look large and ears to look small.

But if you put that 20mm on the camcorder, and the multiplier takes
effect, you would have to be 7.2 times further away from your subject to
get the same framing, and you would be at the same distance from the
subject as if you had used a 144mm lens on your eos camera.  This is
also the reason that you would get the same perspective if you shot a
portrait from a longer distance with the 20mm lens and cropped the
frame--you would get a very pleasing perspective, although you sharpness
and grain wouldn't be good.

There is one non-equivalency between the 20mm on the camcorder and the
144mm on the eos camera though--your depth of field.  While on the
camcorder you would have the same depth of field as a wide shot on your
eos, the 144 on the eos, giving the same framing and perspective as the
camcorder with the 20mm lens, would have a very shallow depth of field
if the lenses were set at the same f-stop.

It boils down to these rules of thumb that most people here are already
familiar with:

"Perspective depends only on your distance from the subject"

and

"Depth of field depends on the magnification of your subject" (note that
this "rule" is an approximation that I am not sure holds at the extremes
of focal length--there was a thread about this a month or two ago).

Mike
*
****
*******
***********************************************************
*  For list instructions, including unsubscribe, see:
*    http://www.a1.nl/phomepag/markerink/eos_list.htm
***********************************************************

Reply via email to