> What about one or more extension tubes?  They won't compromise optical
> quality and they still allow TTL metering and automatic aperture function.

Oh,  but they do degrade optical performance.
Otherwise we could just take any lens,  add
an extension tube and make it a macro lens.
(Canon wouldn't need a 50 2.5 macro lens in
that case.)

Extension tubes cause lenses to be used out
of spec,  which causes reduced performance.

The softness becomes very apparent with
internal-focus lenses and zooms,  e.g. the
70-200.

Extension tubes also cause substantial light
loss (can be several f/stops!).

What now,  diopter lenses or extension tube?

You can't really win.  A good two-element
diopter lens like the 500D could probably
outperform an extension tube,  but it all
depends on the main lens used.

The original question asked about hiking and
backpacking,  so I would imagine that the
extention tube would be a bit more rugged
(no glass to break),  but at the cost of a
larger footprint in the bag.

Here's another "wild" idea:  along with the
70-200 pack a Canon 28-135 IS and Novoflex
inverter ring.  This will allow you to use
the 28-135 (inverted, i.e. front-to-front)
as a super diopter lens with extremely good
results.  (I think someone posted the link
in this group several moons ago.)

This option is much heavier than the first
two,  but with the added benefit of having
a wideangle and normal zoom lens available
for landscapes and such.

Lars
-- 
 .~.   Lars Michael
 /V\   [EMAIL PROTECTED]
/(_)\  http://www.larsmichael.com/
^^ ^^
*
****
*******
***********************************************************
*  For list instructions, including unsubscribe, see:
*    http://www.a1.nl/phomepag/markerink/eos_list.htm
***********************************************************

Reply via email to