>I have the Chasseurs d'Images right here. They tested some lenses with th= >e 10D/300D and the 1Ds. The conclusions are very simple... Average lenses >perform better with the 10D/300D that on normal film cameras. They perfor= >m very poorly on the 1Ds camera. The explanation they give makes sense and >= is easy to understand. The fact that the 10D/300D sensor is smaller, only >th= e center of the lens is being used (the center is better than the >edges). T= he 1Ds is a full frame sensor, and therefore, any imperfection >of the lens c= an be seen on the picture, especially distorsion and >vignetting. > >What they are saying about the 1Ds is not that the Camera does not perfor= >m well with lens, but rather that it does not forgive the poor quality of a >lens, at all. What they also say is that, while, by the book, the camera = >is compatible with all EF lenses, only select few can be successfully used >o= n that camera because of it's very low tolerance to mediocre quality. >They = do not list lenses that do not perform well with the 1Ds, but they >conclude that if you are thinking of getting the 1Ds, don't think about >lesser lenses... > >They also say that the problem should not be present on the 1D Mark II >because of the size of the sensor that is a bit smaller. The 10D/300D giv= >e impressive results with most average to good quality lenses... And >accord= ing to these tests, the 10D/300D kill the 1Ds when used with >average quality lenses, because these two cameras make partial use of the >lens... > >Voil=E0... If some of you feel they need more information from the articl= >e, please let me know. I am hesitant to translate it for you because it's >fe= w pages long, with a bunch of graphs...
I would like to add some information. I shoot my IDs from last august. I use it with, exactly, a 14mm f2.8, a 15mm f2.8, a 50mm f1.8, a 28-70mm f2.8, a 28-1345 IS, a 24-85mm, a 35-105mm, and a 100-400 IS. Of course pictures taken with L lenses are very good but talking about defects: 1. The extreme wides, 14, 15 and 16-35 have fringing (chromatic aberration) but it is not a constant defect. Under some circumstances it appears and under others it doesn't. Up to now I haven't been able to determinate exactly when is going to be in my image. So I take a lot and after I discard the worse. Vignetting may be severe but I shoot mainly in strong day light so, closing diaphragm, it's not an issue. Distortion is the same than with film. 2. The non L lenses 15mm, 28-135mm, 35-105 and 50mm produce images not at the level of the L lenses, the same happens with my EOS 1V, but they are not at all bad images. Sharpness is a little behind, and vignetting and distortion at same level than before. I can use them perfectly knowing that, mainly, they will be a little bit less crisp. So my opinion, based in my experience, is that you can use any lens from Canon catalogue without any fear. As better the lens is the better will be the output. Extreme wides will be, for sure, redesigned in the future when new lense will be launched but, as they are now and with some precautions, may be perfectly used and get very nice pictures. Felix * **** ******* *********************************************************** * For list instructions, including unsubscribe, see: * http://www.a1.nl/phomepag/markerink/eos_list.htm ***********************************************************
