----[Please read http://ercoupers.com/disclaimer.htm before following any
advice in this forum.]----
Hi John;
Thanks for the email. He's a good guy and absolutely does make a valid
point, albeit off my subject. My contention is that a keen observer, not
someone from AOPA or EAA, who knows the Ercoupe and what the D Model mod
was, should have picked up on the wording and spoken up. It didn't happen,
so we're living with the rule, and so be it. I'm not looking to start a
suit with the Fed but rather very disappointed because it didn't happen. I
realize why it didn't happen, thus my latest in a long line of criticism of
the alleged type club.
I'm always wondering how many other airplanes this paragraph affects. Not
really interested in just the ones who are looking to somehow downgrade
their GW to fit, but how many other models out there have an STC to increase
their GW with only an adjustment. I'm also wondering if the rule was
actually intended to prohibit those airplanes that have extensive mods done
in order to improve the gross weight. Case in point, the Bonanza, of which
I'm a bit familiar with. Among other mods, if you add tip tanks, your GW is
increased by 100 lbs. If you remove them, you loose the GW. Please don't
think that I'm suggesting the Bo is included in Sportie, I'm only trying to
make a point. Maybe floats, or bigger engines or something like that.
So I guess what I would like to know is simply, how many other models of
aircraft, that were built with a GW that allows them the pleasure of fitting
into the Sport Rule, have a non structural STC to increase the weight. An
additional and even better question would be why would an a/c who actually
had the reverse mod in the past also be prohibited from Sport? An
enterprising person with the right connections could maybe offer up an STC
to do the reverse and have it blessed. The D Model crowd may buy into it
with both wallets!
Al
-- Original Message -----
From: "John Roach" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>
To: "A DeMarzo" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>
Cc: "Ercoupe Hangar Flying" <[email protected]>
Sent: Friday, October 06, 2006 5:13 PM
Subject: Re: [COUPERS-FLYIN] Re: LSA for a 415-D
Al,
Syd does have an important point. The FAA decided to make the rule the way
it was made. The rule had been under discussion for quite a while. If I
remember correctly, the weight limit was changed upward from the original
proposal. The decision to not allow certificated aircraft to download
gross weight and still be sport pilot eligible was debated as well. In
debates, someone always wins and someone always looses. The final decision
was up to the FAA. And, like it or not, their decision stands. Perhaps a
more aggressive approach by the EOC would have made a difference. But to
be realistic, it is much more probable that it would not have changed the
FAAs decision. I personally think that the EAA would have liked to see
this part of the decision go the other way. And, the EAA has a lot more
impact on the FAA than the EOC and probably more than any of the type
clubs or even all of them together. Ercoupes are not the only aircraft
affected by this part of the rule. The rule can be criticized by any of
us. But, in the long run, it's a lot better than no sport pilot rule.
John Roach
N 2427H
==============================================================================
To leave this forum go to: http://ercoupers.com/lists.htm