----[Please read http://ercoupers.com/disclaimer.htm before following any advice in this forum.]----


 

Harry,

 

I think it was NY Mayor Bloomberg who said that the east side of Manhatten was difficult airspace.

 

As I recall, he said that people sometimes go up the East River instead of another waterway.  He said that when pilots pass over the 59th street bridge, they realize they are in the wrong place and headed into the La Guardia control zone so they try to turn around.

 

The river is only about .13 miles wide there (240 yards).

 

It seems that the Cirrus did try to turn around after passing the 59th street bridge and shortly thereafter a lady on the ground (who was not a pilot) saw the plane.  It was doing “aerobatics” she thought and she wondered why it was doing it there.  Then it dropped one wing and turned, then it leveled out and passed out of her line of sight.  Then it impacted.

 

All speculation but it may be they realized they were in the wrong place, tried to make the turn (chandelle?), stalled (maybe an accelerated stall in a bank during the U turn) and if they recovered, it was without a way to avoid the building.

 

That would have been a good time to pull the parachute handle.

 

Alas.

 

Just guessing.

 

It seems that the CFI flying with him was not familiar with the New York local area.

 

As it says on a poster I saw, something like: Aviation, like no other endeavor, is not forgiving of error.

 

Ed Burkhead

http://edburkhead.com

ed -at- edburkhead???.com          (change -at- to @ and remove "???")

==============================================================================
To leave this forum go to: http://ercoupers.com/lists.htm

Reply via email to