On 1.6.09 13:47, Allen Wirfs-Brock wrote:
The main reason we needed to deal with such partial property descriptors is to 
enable the use case of Object.defineProperty where someone wants to set the 
state of some specific attribute of an already existing property.  We wanted to 
enable a programmer to, for example, write:
        Object.defineProperty(myObj,"myProp", {configurable:false});
Rather than:
        var desc= Object.getOwnPropertyDescriptor(myObj,"myProp");
        desc.configurable=false;
        Object.defineProperty(myObj,"myProp", desc);

If we are going to allow such modification of individual attributes (or subsets 
of attributes) then we need to specify the acceptable attribute transformations 
for an existing property.  That is specified by the algorithm steps of 
[[DefineOwnProperty]]. The specific encoding use within internal property 
descriptors to represent the intention to change or to leave unmodified a 
particular attribute doesn't significantly change the complexity of 
[[DefineOwnProperty]]. In earlier drafts we actually experimented with using 
fully populated property descriptors and attribute fields with three possible 
values logic (true, false, unspecified).  This actually added some complexity 
to the specification (for example, we couldn't use the internal Boolean type to 
define the expected field values) so we decided to use the absence of attribute 
field to indicate that its value is not being explicitly specified.

It would be simpler to implement, less complicated to understand, and more 
naturally named if this only-twiddle-attributes functionality were its own 
method -- for example, Object.alterProperty or Object.modifyProperty or 
Brendan's Object.changeProperty.  For a rough specification, simply start with 
a property descriptor initialized from [[GetOwnProperty]], crib the steps of 
the current ToPropertyDescriptor that deal with the boolean fields of property 
descriptors to change attributes, then call [[DefineOwnProperty]] with the 
desired property and potentially-modified descriptor.  This would allow 
twiddling of individual bits, but it wouldn't add another possibility for the 
value of every field in a property descriptor.

Jeff
_______________________________________________
es-discuss mailing list
[email protected]
https://mail.mozilla.org/listinfo/es-discuss

Reply via email to