Boris Zbarsky wrote:
On 7/5/12 10:37 PM, Brendan Eich wrote:
Does the spec really mandate onunload etc. definitely being called in
all cases?
Pretty much, yes. Unless I'm misreading it.
That is impossible in a great number of cases (machine hard
reset, e.g.)
Any sort of hardware limitations get Get Out Of Spec Free cards,
basically.
And if you take the blue pill and the virtualization Matrix has you?
This is a silly part of the spec. I tried prevailing on Hixie years ago,
to no avail. He had some reductionistic view of "hardware" vs.
"software", but tiered virtualization (hypervisor or just browser VM)
means there must be a way to kill guests cold, without waiting for them
to stall with onunload etc.
and anyway it enables DoS attacks.
Yep. So I doubt anyone will implement the spec on this, if it says
what I think it does, and then the spec will get changed.
Unimplementable and unimplemented spec is bad spec. Let's fix it.
Suggestions welcome -- and maybe a good cop to my bad cop since I failed
last time?
/be
_______________________________________________
es-discuss mailing list
[email protected]
https://mail.mozilla.org/listinfo/es-discuss