Hello,

Been wondering about realism with karplus strong.

Mistakes are a big part of playing, I'm wondering if there's a way to
emulate the subtleties of missing an ideally played note on a fret. There's
nuances to playing, slightly miss-plays of notes, slightly deadening, or
slight changes based on where you're holding the note down on a fret...

And also how long a note is held down (even when note value is supposed to
be consistent/regular). We're talking about microscopic details here, that
aren't that easy to recognise, but nonetheless are present in playing. KP
has fixed decay. Ridiculous idea, but is there a way to emulate the
microscope randomness of actual playing? For instance notes don't always
decay perfectly when playing, you can have mutes, accidental or not (from
hand interference), that add to a cohesive realism.

https://www.youtube.com/shorts/ZeWUC68nR1M

I think that video is a decent example, when he starts playing bach. If you
were to emulate with karplus strong algorithm, you'd have a consistent
decay of a note at each play, but that's not the case in actual guitar
playing. I also think there's some subtleties of fretting, whether your
finger is bang on the middle, or slightly off/lopsided, I think this
changes something, I can't put my finger on it (pardon the pun), but seems
like there's minutiae that exists in guitar playing that isn't perfectly
emulated in digital algorithms yet (unless I'm sorely mistaken).

My question to the group is, how do you start even quantifying/analysing
this phenomenon so you can model it? Is slightly adapting decay enough, is
slightly or randomly modifying tiniest of tuning of notes to account for
slightly off balance fretting enough to add an extra dimension of realism?
_______________________________________________
Faudiostream-users mailing list
[email protected]
https://lists.sourceforge.net/lists/listinfo/faudiostream-users

Reply via email to