Benjamin Larsson <[email protected]> added the comment: On 11/21/2010 01:53 PM, Chris wrote: > > Chris <[email protected]> added the comment: > >> Yes, there seems to be incorrect interleaving. It goes away when >re-encoding >> the audio. I think -acodec copy and AC3 do not work together correctly. >> Isn't there even an issue open about that already? > > Why FFmpeg sets a WAVE Format Tag instead of the Original AC3 Tag? > > Extensible is not supported by Standalone Players neither allmost all Software > Players. > > Even WMP doesnt play fine with this file. The Ac3 is by the Way a Stdio Ac3. > SO > why should i reencode it ? > ITS FINE! > > Muxing with at least 3 Other tools work fine. (Avimuxgui, Nandub/VDubMOD and > AVIDemux by Mean) > > I wouldn t bother u Guy with it but i simply need a Commandline muxxing Tool > to > Mux an AVI (Xvid) + Ac3 (5.1 448). > > Introducing a header Format into a Tool doesnt help if no player can use it. >
I'm all for not creating the waveformat extensible header for ac3 in avi if lots of players don't support the files. Any libavformat/libavcodec based player will support both types of files anyway. There is a patch by Jai here https://roundup.ffmpeg.org/issue1498 MvH Benjamin Larsson ________________________________________________ FFmpeg issue tracker <[email protected]> <https://roundup.ffmpeg.org/issue2371> ________________________________________________
