Eric Dannewitz wrote:

Of course you'd like it to work with MusicXML. Isn't that YOUR company?

Where is the guess work in MIDI files? Example, I can do something in Digital Performer, load it into Logic, and it looks the same. Triplets come out as triplets. Etc. But I load the same file into Finale, and the triplet comes out wrong. Or maybe Finale decides that a whole note isn't exactly a whole note anymore. Hell, even Cakewalk usually does a better job importing MIDI than Finale.

I'm concerned with it just getting the notes and rhythms right, not all the other stuff that goes into music notation. If it could import Midi's 99% better I'd be happy.


Now that MakeMusic have climbed into bed with NativeInstruments and Garritan, they'll next climb into bed with Logic and license their quantization and importing algorithms?

Why not? Worse things could happen, our upgrade dollars could certainly be spent much worsely, as long as the midi import is improved. That would also improve Hyperscribe, one would hope, so that Finale could better interpret what we play.

--
David H. Bailey
[EMAIL PROTECTED]
_______________________________________________
Finale mailing list
Finale@shsu.edu
http://lists.shsu.edu/mailman/listinfo/finale

Reply via email to