On 18 Jan 2007 at 23:55, Daniel Wolf wrote: > David W. Fenton wrote: > > Does that mean that when playing with the organ you're not playing > > in a mean-tone temperament? Tuning a viol to a temperament based on > > tempered 5ths (i.e., a well temperament) is easier than tuning to > > one based around pure thirds (i.e., a mean temperament, which has > > 5ths that vary by different amounts) > > Wrong. In standard meantone, all fifths are tempered by a > quarter-comma
But we weren't talking about quarter-comma, which is basically unusable on a keyboard instrument without split keys for anything but a very limited repertory. > and the good major third is always the sum of four > (octave-reduced) fifths. Any meantone-like temperament can be fretted > with straight frets (actually 12tet can be thought of as 1/11 comma > !), although having all accidentals available on all strings may > require more than 12 frets per octave. (At which point it is useful to > consider larger equal temperaments, i.e. 31tet for quarter-comma > meantone, 19tet for third comma, etc.). Uh, I don't know of any historical gambas with more than 12 frets per octave. > The unequal circulating temperaments, so-called well-temperaments like > the popular Kirnberger III, Werckmeister III or Young, do not have one > size of fifth, and there is no consisting summing up of series of > fifths into the best major third. They cannot be fretted with straight > frets, requiring crooked frets or fretlets (which do not extend all > the way across the fingerboard); thus tie-on frets, as on lutes or > viols, will not work. There is a real connection here between use of > unequal temperaments and a decline, from the 17th to the 18th century, > in the use of fretted instruments in the continuo ensemble. This does not match my experience at all. We restrung our instruments and retuned our frets at the beginning of the test and we had desperate problems with tuning because of it. And we were playing 17th-century music (early and late). When this was thrown together with the organ (our keyboard player was our tuner, so he touched it up before every rehearsal), it was a disaster. Maybe we're just completely incompetent. -- David W. Fenton http://dfenton.com David Fenton Associates http://dfenton.com/DFA/ _______________________________________________ Finale mailing list [email protected] http://lists.shsu.edu/mailman/listinfo/finale
