Woops. I pasted the wrong thing for scope=provided. The scope=provided output looks like this:
[INFO] --- maven-dependency-plugin:2.1:tree (default-cli) @ simple-rsl-transitive-application --- [INFO] info.rvin.itest:simple-rsl-transitive-application:swf:1.0-SNAPSHOT [INFO] +- info.rvin.itest.transitive-rsl-dependency:B:swc:1.0-SNAPSHOT:provided [INFO] | \- com.adobe.flex.framework:air-framework:pom:4.5.0.18623:provided [INFO] | +- com.adobe.flex.framework:common-framework:pom:4.5.0.18623:provided [INFO] | | +- com.adobe.flex.framework:advancedgrids:swc:4.5.0.18623:provided [INFO] | | +- com.adobe.flex.framework:authoringsupport:swc:4.5.0.18623:provided [INFO] | | +- com.adobe.flex.framework:charts:swc:4.5.0.18623:provided [INFO] | | +- com.adobe.flex.framework:core:swc:4.5.0.18623:provided [INFO] | | +- com.adobe.flex.framework:flash-integration:swc:4.5.0.18623:provided [INFO] | | +- com.adobe.flex.framework:framework:swc:4.5.0.18623:provided [INFO] | | +- com.adobe.flex.framework:mx:swc:4.5.0.18623:provided [INFO] | | +- com.adobe.flex.framework:osmf:swc:4.5.0.18623:provided [INFO] | | +- com.adobe.flex.framework:rpc:swc:4.5.0.18623:provided [INFO] | | +- com.adobe.flex.framework:spark:swc:4.5.0.18623:provided [INFO] | | +- com.adobe.flex.framework:sparkskins:swc:4.5.0.18623:provided [INFO] | | +- com.adobe.flex.framework:spark_dmv:swc:4.5.0.18623:provided [INFO] | | +- com.adobe.flex.framework:textLayout:swc:4.5.0.18623:provided [INFO] | | +- com.adobe.flex.framework:framework:zip:configs:4.5.0.18623:provided [INFO] | | +- com.adobe.flex.framework:advancedgrids:rb.swc:4.5.0.18623:provided [INFO] | | +- com.adobe.flex.framework:charts:rb.swc:4.5.0.18623:provided [INFO] | | +- com.adobe.flex.framework:framework:rb.swc:4.5.0.18623:provided [INFO] | | +- com.adobe.flex.framework:mx:rb.swc:4.5.0.18623:provided [INFO] | | +- com.adobe.flex.framework:osmf:rb.swc:4.5.0.18623:provided [INFO] | | +- com.adobe.flex.framework:rpc:rb.swc:4.5.0.18623:provided [INFO] | | +- com.adobe.flex.framework:spark:rb.swc:4.5.0.18623:provided [INFO] | | +- com.adobe.flex.framework:textLayout:rb.swc:4.5.0.18623:provided [INFO] | | \- com.adobe.flex.framework:flash-integration:rb.swc:4.5.0.18623:provided [INFO] | +- com.adobe.flex.framework:aircore:swc:4.5.0.18623:provided [INFO] | +- com.adobe.flex.framework:airframework:swc:4.5.0.18623:provided [INFO] | +- com.adobe.flex.framework:airglobal:swc:4.5.0.18623:provided [INFO] | +- com.adobe.flex.framework:airspark:swc:4.5.0.18623:provided [INFO] | +- com.adobe.flex.framework:applicationupdater:swc:4.5.0.18623:provided [INFO] | +- com.adobe.flex.framework:applicationupdater_ui:swc:4.5.0.18623:provided [INFO] | +- com.adobe.flex.framework:servicemonitor:swc:4.5.0.18623:provided [INFO] | +- com.adobe.flex.framework:airframework:rb.swc:4.5.0.18623:provided [INFO] | \- com.adobe.flex.framework:airspark:rb.swc:4.5.0.18623:provided [INFO] \- info.rvin.itest.transitive-rsl-dependency:A:swc:1.0-SNAPSHOT:test [INFO] +- com.adobe.flex.framework:flex-framework:pom:4.5.0.18623:test [INFO] | \- com.adobe.flex.framework:playerglobal:rb.swc:4.5.0.18623:test [INFO] +- com.adobe.flex.framework:playerglobal:swc:10.2:4.5.0.18623:test [INFO] \- info.rvin.itest.transitive-rsl-dependency:internalLib:swc:1.0-SNAPSHOT:test [INFO] ------------------------------------------------------------------------ On Thu, Dec 2, 2010 at 9:04 AM, Ryan Gardner <[email protected]> wrote: > Cool. I'll try that. > > I've been looking at the mvn dependency:tree output to see what makes > the RSL case different in maven's eyes. > > When using a normal scope (so it defaults to compile) - the > dependency:tree looks of my test case looks like this: > > [INFO] --- maven-dependency-plugin:2.1:tree (default-cli) @ > simple-rsl-transitive-application --- > [INFO] info.rvin.itest:simple-rsl-transitive-application:swf:1.0-SNAPSHOT > [INFO] +- info.rvin.itest.transitive-rsl-dependency:B:swc:1.0-SNAPSHOT:compile > [INFO] | \- com.adobe.flex.framework:air-framework:pom:4.5.0.18623:compile > [INFO] | +- > com.adobe.flex.framework:common-framework:pom:4.5.0.18623:compile > [INFO] | | +- > com.adobe.flex.framework:advancedgrids:swc:4.5.0.18623:compile > [INFO] | | +- > com.adobe.flex.framework:authoringsupport:swc:4.5.0.18623:compile > [INFO] | | +- com.adobe.flex.framework:charts:swc:4.5.0.18623:compile > [INFO] | | +- com.adobe.flex.framework:core:swc:4.5.0.18623:compile > [INFO] | | +- > com.adobe.flex.framework:flash-integration:swc:4.5.0.18623:compile > [INFO] | | +- com.adobe.flex.framework:framework:swc:4.5.0.18623:compile > [INFO] | | +- com.adobe.flex.framework:mx:swc:4.5.0.18623:compile > [INFO] | | +- com.adobe.flex.framework:osmf:swc:4.5.0.18623:compile > [INFO] | | +- com.adobe.flex.framework:rpc:swc:4.5.0.18623:compile > [INFO] | | +- com.adobe.flex.framework:spark:swc:4.5.0.18623:compile > [INFO] | | +- com.adobe.flex.framework:sparkskins:swc:4.5.0.18623:compile > [INFO] | | +- com.adobe.flex.framework:spark_dmv:swc:4.5.0.18623:compile > [INFO] | | +- com.adobe.flex.framework:textLayout:swc:4.5.0.18623:compile > [INFO] | | +- > com.adobe.flex.framework:framework:zip:configs:4.5.0.18623:compile > [INFO] | | +- > com.adobe.flex.framework:advancedgrids:rb.swc:4.5.0.18623:compile > [INFO] | | +- com.adobe.flex.framework:charts:rb.swc:4.5.0.18623:compile > [INFO] | | +- > com.adobe.flex.framework:framework:rb.swc:4.5.0.18623:compile > [INFO] | | +- com.adobe.flex.framework:mx:rb.swc:4.5.0.18623:compile > [INFO] | | +- com.adobe.flex.framework:osmf:rb.swc:4.5.0.18623:compile > [INFO] | | +- com.adobe.flex.framework:rpc:rb.swc:4.5.0.18623:compile > [INFO] | | +- com.adobe.flex.framework:spark:rb.swc:4.5.0.18623:compile > [INFO] | | +- > com.adobe.flex.framework:textLayout:rb.swc:4.5.0.18623:compile > [INFO] | | \- > com.adobe.flex.framework:flash-integration:rb.swc:4.5.0.18623:compile > [INFO] | +- com.adobe.flex.framework:aircore:swc:4.5.0.18623:compile > [INFO] | +- com.adobe.flex.framework:airframework:swc:4.5.0.18623:compile > [INFO] | +- com.adobe.flex.framework:airglobal:swc:4.5.0.18623:compile > [INFO] | +- com.adobe.flex.framework:airspark:swc:4.5.0.18623:compile > [INFO] | +- > com.adobe.flex.framework:applicationupdater:swc:4.5.0.18623:compile > [INFO] | +- > com.adobe.flex.framework:applicationupdater_ui:swc:4.5.0.18623:compile > [INFO] | +- > com.adobe.flex.framework:servicemonitor:swc:4.5.0.18623:compile > [INFO] | +- > com.adobe.flex.framework:airframework:rb.swc:4.5.0.18623:compile > [INFO] | \- com.adobe.flex.framework:airspark:rb.swc:4.5.0.18623:compile > [INFO] \- info.rvin.itest.transitive-rsl-dependency:A:swc:1.0-SNAPSHOT:test > (scope not updated to compile) > [INFO] +- com.adobe.flex.framework:flex-framework:pom:4.5.0.18623:test > [INFO] | \- com.adobe.flex.framework:playerglobal:rb.swc:4.5.0.18623:test > [INFO] +- com.adobe.flex.framework:playerglobal:swc:10.2:4.5.0.18623:test > [INFO] \- > info.rvin.itest.transitive-rsl-dependency:internalLib:swc:1.0-SNAPSHOT:test > > > When I use scope=RSL the output looks like this: > > [INFO] --- maven-dependency-plugin:2.1:tree (default-cli) @ > simple-rsl-transitive-application --- > [INFO] info.rvin.itest:simple-rsl-transitive-application:swf:1.0-SNAPSHOT > [INFO] +- info.rvin.itest.transitive-rsl-dependency:B:swc:1.0-SNAPSHOT:rsl > [INFO] | \- com.adobe.flex.framework:air-framework:pom:4.5.0.18623:runtime > [INFO] | +- > com.adobe.flex.framework:common-framework:pom:4.5.0.18623:runtime > [INFO] | | +- > com.adobe.flex.framework:advancedgrids:swc:4.5.0.18623:runtime > [INFO] | | +- > com.adobe.flex.framework:authoringsupport:swc:4.5.0.18623:runtime > [INFO] | | +- com.adobe.flex.framework:charts:swc:4.5.0.18623:runtime > [INFO] | | +- com.adobe.flex.framework:core:swc:4.5.0.18623:runtime > [INFO] | | +- > com.adobe.flex.framework:flash-integration:swc:4.5.0.18623:runtime > [INFO] | | +- com.adobe.flex.framework:framework:swc:4.5.0.18623:runtime > [INFO] | | +- com.adobe.flex.framework:mx:swc:4.5.0.18623:runtime > [INFO] | | +- com.adobe.flex.framework:osmf:swc:4.5.0.18623:runtime > [INFO] | | +- com.adobe.flex.framework:rpc:swc:4.5.0.18623:runtime > [INFO] | | +- com.adobe.flex.framework:spark:swc:4.5.0.18623:runtime > [INFO] | | +- com.adobe.flex.framework:sparkskins:swc:4.5.0.18623:runtime > [INFO] | | +- com.adobe.flex.framework:spark_dmv:swc:4.5.0.18623:runtime > [INFO] | | +- com.adobe.flex.framework:textLayout:swc:4.5.0.18623:runtime > [INFO] | | +- > com.adobe.flex.framework:framework:zip:configs:4.5.0.18623:runtime > [INFO] | | +- > com.adobe.flex.framework:advancedgrids:rb.swc:4.5.0.18623:runtime > [INFO] | | +- com.adobe.flex.framework:charts:rb.swc:4.5.0.18623:runtime > [INFO] | | +- > com.adobe.flex.framework:framework:rb.swc:4.5.0.18623:runtime > [INFO] | | +- com.adobe.flex.framework:mx:rb.swc:4.5.0.18623:runtime > [INFO] | | +- com.adobe.flex.framework:osmf:rb.swc:4.5.0.18623:runtime > [INFO] | | +- com.adobe.flex.framework:rpc:rb.swc:4.5.0.18623:runtime > [INFO] | | +- com.adobe.flex.framework:spark:rb.swc:4.5.0.18623:runtime > [INFO] | | +- > com.adobe.flex.framework:textLayout:rb.swc:4.5.0.18623:runtime > [INFO] | | \- > com.adobe.flex.framework:flash-integration:rb.swc:4.5.0.18623:runtime > [INFO] | +- com.adobe.flex.framework:aircore:swc:4.5.0.18623:runtime > [INFO] | +- com.adobe.flex.framework:airframework:swc:4.5.0.18623:runtime > [INFO] | +- com.adobe.flex.framework:airglobal:swc:4.5.0.18623:runtime > [INFO] | +- com.adobe.flex.framework:airspark:swc:4.5.0.18623:runtime > [INFO] | +- > com.adobe.flex.framework:applicationupdater:swc:4.5.0.18623:runtime > [INFO] | +- > com.adobe.flex.framework:applicationupdater_ui:swc:4.5.0.18623:runtime > [INFO] | +- > com.adobe.flex.framework:servicemonitor:swc:4.5.0.18623:runtime > [INFO] | +- > com.adobe.flex.framework:airframework:rb.swc:4.5.0.18623:runtime > [INFO] | \- com.adobe.flex.framework:airspark:rb.swc:4.5.0.18623:runtime > [INFO] \- info.rvin.itest.transitive-rsl-dependency:A:swc:1.0-SNAPSHOT:test > (scope not updated to runtime) > [INFO] +- com.adobe.flex.framework:flex-framework:pom:4.5.0.18623:test > [INFO] | \- com.adobe.flex.framework:playerglobal:rb.swc:4.5.0.18623:test > [INFO] +- com.adobe.flex.framework:playerglobal:swc:10.2:4.5.0.18623:test > [INFO] \- > info.rvin.itest.transitive-rsl-dependency:internalLib:swc:1.0-SNAPSHOT:test > > > The most noticeable thing is that the scope of all the RSL > dependencies changes to runtime. The best we can probably expect of > maven to do is to make dependencies of a custom scope inherit the same > scope as the parent - which would make them all become rsl scope > instead of runtime scope. > > This would match the behavior of using one of the builtin scopes - > such as "provided" - if you use scope=provided the dependency tree > looks like this: > > [INFO] --- maven-dependency-plugin:2.1:tree (default-cli) @ > simple-rsl-transitive-application --- > [INFO] info.rvin.itest:simple-rsl-transitive-application:swf:1.0-SNAPSHOT > [INFO] +- info.rvin.itest.transitive-rsl-dependency:B:swc:1.0-SNAPSHOT:compile > [INFO] | \- com.adobe.flex.framework:air-framework:pom:4.5.0.18623:compile > [INFO] | +- > com.adobe.flex.framework:common-framework:pom:4.5.0.18623:compile > [INFO] | | +- > com.adobe.flex.framework:advancedgrids:swc:4.5.0.18623:compile > [INFO] | | +- > com.adobe.flex.framework:authoringsupport:swc:4.5.0.18623:compile > [INFO] | | +- com.adobe.flex.framework:charts:swc:4.5.0.18623:compile > [INFO] | | +- com.adobe.flex.framework:core:swc:4.5.0.18623:compile > [INFO] | | +- > com.adobe.flex.framework:flash-integration:swc:4.5.0.18623:compile > [INFO] | | +- com.adobe.flex.framework:framework:swc:4.5.0.18623:compile > [INFO] | | +- com.adobe.flex.framework:mx:swc:4.5.0.18623:compile > [INFO] | | +- com.adobe.flex.framework:osmf:swc:4.5.0.18623:compile > [INFO] | | +- com.adobe.flex.framework:rpc:swc:4.5.0.18623:compile > [INFO] | | +- com.adobe.flex.framework:spark:swc:4.5.0.18623:compile > [INFO] | | +- com.adobe.flex.framework:sparkskins:swc:4.5.0.18623:compile > [INFO] | | +- com.adobe.flex.framework:spark_dmv:swc:4.5.0.18623:compile > [INFO] | | +- com.adobe.flex.framework:textLayout:swc:4.5.0.18623:compile > [INFO] | | +- > com.adobe.flex.framework:framework:zip:configs:4.5.0.18623:compile > [INFO] | | +- > com.adobe.flex.framework:advancedgrids:rb.swc:4.5.0.18623:compile > [INFO] | | +- com.adobe.flex.framework:charts:rb.swc:4.5.0.18623:compile > [INFO] | | +- > com.adobe.flex.framework:framework:rb.swc:4.5.0.18623:compile > [INFO] | | +- com.adobe.flex.framework:mx:rb.swc:4.5.0.18623:compile > [INFO] | | +- com.adobe.flex.framework:osmf:rb.swc:4.5.0.18623:compile > [INFO] | | +- com.adobe.flex.framework:rpc:rb.swc:4.5.0.18623:compile > [INFO] | | +- com.adobe.flex.framework:spark:rb.swc:4.5.0.18623:compile > [INFO] | | +- > com.adobe.flex.framework:textLayout:rb.swc:4.5.0.18623:compile > [INFO] | | \- > com.adobe.flex.framework:flash-integration:rb.swc:4.5.0.18623:compile > [INFO] | +- com.adobe.flex.framework:aircore:swc:4.5.0.18623:compile > [INFO] | +- com.adobe.flex.framework:airframework:swc:4.5.0.18623:compile > [INFO] | +- com.adobe.flex.framework:airglobal:swc:4.5.0.18623:compile > [INFO] | +- com.adobe.flex.framework:airspark:swc:4.5.0.18623:compile > [INFO] | +- > com.adobe.flex.framework:applicationupdater:swc:4.5.0.18623:compile > [INFO] | +- > com.adobe.flex.framework:applicationupdater_ui:swc:4.5.0.18623:compile > [INFO] | +- > com.adobe.flex.framework:servicemonitor:swc:4.5.0.18623:compile > [INFO] | +- > com.adobe.flex.framework:airframework:rb.swc:4.5.0.18623:compile > [INFO] | \- com.adobe.flex.framework:airspark:rb.swc:4.5.0.18623:compile > [INFO] \- info.rvin.itest.transitive-rsl-dependency:A:swc:1.0-SNAPSHOT:test > (scope not updated to compile) > [INFO] +- com.adobe.flex.framework:flex-framework:pom:4.5.0.18623:test > [INFO] | \- com.adobe.flex.framework:playerglobal:rb.swc:4.5.0.18623:test > [INFO] +- com.adobe.flex.framework:playerglobal:swc:10.2:4.5.0.18623:test > [INFO] \- > info.rvin.itest.transitive-rsl-dependency:internalLib:swc:1.0-SNAPSHOT:test > > It might be easy to get a patch to maven to make the dependencies of > one of our custom scopes to stay in the same custom scope. Then the > question becomes... is that the behavior that we want? > > My first reaction is... yes - I think that's probably the correct > behavior. It would increase the number of RSLs that you are using > dramatically if you have a large number of transitive dependencies, > but the application should still compile and run (assuming all the > RSLs were deployed and available at runtime). Then if you want to make > some of the dependencies that are being brought in as RSLs no longer > being loaded as RSLs you would then have to <exclude> them and define > them as an explicit compile time dependency - this seems like it would > make the most sense to me. > > There is one other caveat though and that is the <caching> scope. The > RSL will most likely have a transitive dependency upon the framework. > If your main pom says to use caching on the framework it should > override anything being brought in from the RSLs who are saying to use > scope RSL but because of the different scopes I'm not sure that it > will. > > Ryan > > > > > > On Thu, Dec 2, 2010 at 5:33 AM, Tony Lâmpada <[email protected]> wrote: >> Ryan, this is how you go about debugging tests with maven: >> http://maven.apache.org/plugins/maven-surefire-plugin/examples/debugging.html >> >> Please keep digging. >> I desperately need the results of your research. :-) >> >> Thanks >> Tony Lâmpada >> >> >> On Dec 1, 7:34 pm, Marvin Froeder <[email protected]> wrote: >>> On Wed, Dec 1, 2010 at 7:27 PM, Ryan Gardner <[email protected]> wrote: >>> >>> > It's pretty obvious that maven hates custom scopes - so much so that >>> > they are threatening with a warning to stop even compiling projects >>> > that have them defined: >>> >>> > [WARNING] >>> > [WARNING] Some problems were encountered while building the effective >>> > model for >>> > info.rvin.itest:simple-rsl-transitive-application:swf:1.0-SNAPSHOT >>> > [WARNING] 'dependencies.dependency.scope' for >>> > info.rvin.itest.transitive-rsl-dependency:B:swc must be one of >>> > [provided, compile, runtime, test, system] but is 'rsl'. @ line 41, >>> > column 11 >>> > [WARNING] >>> > [WARNING] It is highly recommended to fix these problems because they >>> > threaten the stability of your build. >>> > [WARNING] >>> > [WARNING] For this reason, future Maven versions might no longer >>> > support building such malformed projects. >>> > [WARNING] >>> >>> This warning only exists because I talk maven team to it... originally >>> maven3 just broke the build. Plain and simple, no mercy. >>> >>> > On a positive note, I have determined that it is quite easy to replace >>> > the set of resolved dependencies so it is possible to fix this >>> > behavior without requiring maven to be patched. >>> >>> Patching flexmojos is a bad idea. This is a maven bug, there so must be >>> fixed on maven. It is enough to fix flex SDK bugs inside flexmojos. >>> >>> VELO >> >> -- >> You received this message because you are subscribed to the Google >> Groups "Flex Mojos" group. >> To post to this group, send email to [email protected] >> To unsubscribe from this group, send email to >> [email protected] >> For more options, visit this group at >> http://groups.google.com/group/flex-mojos >> >> http://flexmojos.sonatype.org/ >> > -- You received this message because you are subscribed to the Google Groups "Flex Mojos" group. To post to this group, send email to [email protected] To unsubscribe from this group, send email to [email protected] For more options, visit this group at http://groups.google.com/group/flex-mojos http://flexmojos.sonatype.org/
