CLINTON'S LAST HURRAH: A BAD DEAL THAT WON'T WORK
by
Eric S. Margolis   7 January 2001

This past week in the Mideast was enough to give heart-attacks to all
concerned.  With only days left in office, President Bill Clinton was
desperately trying to push the Arabs and Israel into a peace deal for which
he could take credit.  Israel's tough, embattled prime minister, Ehud
Barak, faces elections next month.  As of now, he seems likely to lose to
Likud Party leader Ariel Sharon, a hardliner and extreme Zionist who vows
to "get tough" with Palestinians.

The only man who may save Barak from defeat is none other than his strange
bedfellow, PLO chief Yasser Arafat.  If Arafat agrees to the latest peace
deal being pressed upon him by partners Clinton and Barak, then, by this
weird symbiosis, Barak will probably win re-election.

Even so, total US support for Israel may wane.  For the past eight years,
Israel has exercised unprecedented influence over the Clinton
Administration, virtually directing US Mideast policy.  Unlike the Clinton
team, which was top heavy with supporters of Israel, the incoming Bush
Administration has few in evidence.  Nor is Bush beholden, as Clinton was,
to pro-Israel financial contributors.  To the contrary, Bush's father,
President George Bush, and his Secretary of State, James Baker, tried to
put pressure on Israel to halt building settlements. As a result,  the
 pro-Israel media accused them of being anti-semites.

The defeat of Al Gore, who had been financed and cultivated for decades by
Israel's US supporters, is being viewed as a blow to Israeli influence in
Washington.

Arafat now faces a deep dilemma.  If he does not make a deal with Barak,
then Sharon, who is hated and feared by Arabs as the potential Milosevic of
the Mideast, could win.  Sharon says he will encourage more Jewish
settlements and crush the current "intifada."  Many Arabs suspect Sharon
favors Serb-style ethnic cleansing of Palestinians from the West Bank and
Gaza.  Sharon has long insisted that Jordan should become the Palestinian
homeland.

Arafat does not want to deal with Sharon.  So what to do?  The deal he is
being offered by the US-Israeli tag team is the best to date: 95% of the
Occupied Territories; maybe a slice of East Jerusalem, including the
all-important Haram al-Sharif mosque(though Barak now denies it); fixed
borders.  Whether the Palestinian state will be a series of blobs
surrounded by Israeli territory and Jewish-only roads remains uncertain.
 Israel will retail troops on the Jordan River for three years.  Palestine
will be demilitarized and may have no borders with the outside world.

But the thorniest question, as this column has written for years, is the 4
million Palestinian refugees (plus 400,000 forgotten Syrian refugees from
Israeli-occupied Golan).  The Palestinian Diaspora, the world's largest
number of refugees, will not be allowed the right of return to their lost
homes in what is now Israel, according to Clinton's plan.  Though driven
from their land in 1947-48 and in 1967, the original refugees and their
offspring will remain in squalid camps, apparently without any substantial
compensation or hope for the future.

Arafat, one suspects, longs to make a deal with Barak.  They badly need one
another.  But Arafat cannot enforce any lasting peace that leaves four
million Palestinians stranded.  He dares not, for risk of his own skin.  So
he bobs and weaves, "conditionally accepting" Clinton's plan, waiting for a
miracle to solve this impasse.

This core problem appears insoluble.  Though international law and the UN
call for the refugees to be returned home, there seems no possible way
Israel would ever settle even a quarter of them, though it did find room
for a million Russians, many of whom were not even Jews.  Four million
Palestinians added to Israel's current one million Arabs would make Israel
a predominantly Arab state.  Israel would never permit such racial
dilution.  If it did happen, an Israeli friend says, "I'd be a Jewish
Palestinian!"

Barak did offer to allow back a small number of Palestinian refugees under
the guise of "family reunification."  This was to take heat off Arafat.  No
one will be fooled by this ploy.  The number of Arab refugees allowed to
return to the new Palestinian mini-state may also be limited by the US and
Israel.

If the 11th - hour deal did go through, which is unlikely, Israel would
still be left in the catbird seat.  It would retain control of much
militarily strategic land and water resources.  The resistive Palestinians
would be surrounded by Israeli roads and security forces, and policed by
PLO units.  The big Israeli settlements would remain.  Palestine would
become a military protectorate and economic dependency of Israel.

PM Barak has threatened that if the current deal fails, he will go ahead
with plans to erect high walls around all Palestinian areas, as he says
"totally separating Israeli's" from the Arabs.  This uncomfortably recalls
both the walled-in Jewish ghettos of Eastern Europe, and South Africa's
"apartheid," or "separation policy."  Hopefully, it's pre-election
rhetoric.

Even if Arafat is strongarmed into a shaky peace deal designed to salvage
Clinton's besmirched reputation, his people will reject any pact that
forecloses their right of return.  The Arab states also rejected Clinton's
deal last week.  King Solomon, not Bill Clinton, seems the only person who
can solve this impossible problem.

Copyright:   Eric S. Margolis 2001

************************************************************************
**********************************




To send *personal mail* to Eric Margolis, please do not click reply, but use this link:
mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED]
**************
To UNSUBSCRIBE to this list click the following link and enter the words UNSUBSCRIBE 
FOREIGNC in the body of the email.
mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED]
 

Reply via email to