Perlu kiranya pemerintah pusat mendalami dengan tenang perkembangan di tanah Papua. Jika pendekatan keamanan dan ketahanan yang semata-mata bertolak dari konsep dasar eksistensi negara yang dilakukan, maka harga yang dibayar akan mahal. Pola lama yang sebatas pendekatan 'You kerja-sama ok, you mau yang lain, ok lihat nanti! terbukti justru telah menjadikan urusan demikian ini menjadi urusan internasional. Sebaiknya kita belajar dari kasus Timor Leste dan sebetulnya/akhirnya dalam batas tertentu terjadi di Aceh. Mengenai kasus pelanggaran pemilu 2009 di Papua, di media TV terlihat jelas bagaimana aparat dengan kekuatannya menangkapi pelaku unjuk rasa. Bahkan pengejaran-pengejaran oleh aparat diperlihatkan dapat meredam kekacauan. Tetapi apakah langkah itu akan meredam gejolak atau justru akan sebaliknya? Aksi aparat tidak lepas dari paradigma yang digunakan. Policy analyst yang menganalisis masalah Papua tampaknya masih terbatas pada kalangan intelijen, militer, petinggi pemerintah, atau DPR. Ujung-ujungnya mereka hanya akan berbisik-bisik saja. Padahal masalah ini perlahan-lahan sudah menjadi masalah internasional. Menurut saya selekasnya masalah ini ditangani dengan pendekatan lain. Diperlukan perubahan paradigma. Diperlukan kejelasan visi tentang Papua yang bagaimana yang dibayangkan oleh kita 20 tahun ke depan. Mampukah menjadikannya 20 tahun lagi memiliki karakteristik yang sama dengan wilayah-wilayah lain RI? Bukankah lebih baik membiarkan wilayah itu tumbuh, misalnya dengan tidak berusaha memompa warga RI dari kawasan lain secara massif seperti yang pernah dilakukan di Timor Timur dulu? Bahkan perlukah merubah komposisi etnis dan penganut agama di sana sehingga kaum Muslim dapat secepatnya mengimbangi kaum lokal?. Lihat contoh sejarah bagaimana Timor Timur yang berubah menjadi Timor Leste sekaligus ditandai dengan rubuhnya ratusan tempat ibadah baik gereja maupun masjid yang didirikan dengan dana negara sepanjang pemerintahan RI ada di sana. Oleh sebab itu lakukan perubahan drastis, bahwa pemerintah pusat tidak bermaksud meneruskan paradigma lama. Menurut saya diperlukan perubahan paradigma, perubahan alokasi perhatian dan tidak lagi mengarah pada gelar-menggelar pasukan. Bahkan pemerintah pusat hendaknya berkonsep dengan prinsip minimalis di dalam membangun Papua ke depan. Jangan diabaikan bahwa media-media internasional belum lupa kisah Timor Leste. Forbes terbaru saja masih membuat kenangan peristiwa Timor Timur di dalam sebuah artikel (mengenai ekonomi Timor Leste), yang menyebut angka korban militer RI di sana dengan jumlah mencengangkan: 200.000 jiwa.
--- On Fri, 4/10/09, John Miller <[email protected]> wrote: From: John Miller <[email protected]> Subject: [Forum-Pembaca-KOMPAS] Groups Urge U.S. Action on W Papua Rights as Security Situation Deteriorates To: [email protected], [email protected], [email protected] Date: Friday, April 10, 2009, 9:11 PM Groups Urge U.S. Action on West Papua Rights as Security Situation Deteriorates Contact: John M. Miller, ETAN, +1-718-596-7668 Lynn Barclay, Land is Life, +1-413-320-9510 Ed McWilliams, WPAT, +1-575-648-2078 April 10, 2009 - Human rights organizations have urged the U.S. government and Congress to investigate and act on the continued violations of human rights in West Papua. The letter from the West Papua Advocacy Team (WPAT), Land Is Life, and the East Timor and Indonesia Action Network (ETAN) highlighted the deteriorating security situation in West Papua. As the letter was being sent, the security situation in West Papua continued to deteriorate, with reports of additional armed clashes in the Papuan capital of Jayapura as well as the cities of Biak, Nabire and Wamena. Violent mass arrests were also taking place. "These developments underscore the urgency of U.S. Government and Congressional action to address the crisis in West Papua," said Ed McWilliams of WPAT. McWilliams is a retired senior U.S. Foreign Service Officer who served in Jakarta. "Washington must press Jakarta to deal with Papuans fundamental grievances." The letter called on the U.S. to investigate and condemn recent human rights violations and urged "the U.S. Government and Congress... to press for an internationally facilitated, senior level dialogue between the Indonesian Government and Papuans, including Papuan civil society, to address long-standing Papuan concerns and grievances." Among these are calls for demilitarization of the territory and an end to repression and release of those arrested for peaceful protest, provision of essential services, and self-determination. The letter was also sent to Secretary of State Hillary Rodham Clinton and key members of Congress on East Asian and foreign affairs. A copy of the letter is below. --- April 9, 2009 Senator John F. Kerry, Chair, Foreign Relations Committee Rep. Howard L. Berman, Chair, Foreign Affairs Committee In the past week, the Indonesian military and police have reacted with extreme violence to growing peaceful, public protests in several cities throughout West Papua. On April 6, Brimob police shot at least eleven peaceful protesters, four of whom are in critical condition. A primary-school age child was among the wounded, according to hospital officials. On April 3, police in the West Papua capital Jayapura, broke into the office of the Papuan Customary Council, a legally recognized organization representing over one million Papuans, arresting over a dozen people, an unknown number of whom remained incarcerated. The police also seized Customary Council office files and equipment. In Wamena, the police arrested three Papuan students. This latest spate of government violence targeting peaceful protesters follows a series of arrests of dissenters under charges of "subversion" and "incitement, " two provisions of law dating back to the Dutch colonial era that have been widely criticized by the UN and human rights organizations. In recent months, Papuans have been demonstrating in support of calls for the release of Papuans detained for peaceful exercise of their rights to assembly and freedom of speech, as documented by international human rights organizations such as Amnesty International and Human Rights Watch among others. Demonstrators also have demanded action to afford Papuans their right to self-determination, a right denied them in a referendum organized by the Indonesian government in 1969, widely recognized to have been rigged. Indonesian military and police continue to restrict international efforts to monitor developments in West Papua. Four Dutch journalists last week were detained and deported notwithstanding the fact they held appropriate visas. Those few international officials who do manage to enter West Papua endure disruption of their itineraries by security forces. The 2007 visit by Congressman Eni Faleomavaega and Ambassador Cameron Hume is one example. Indonesian security forces also threaten many Papuans who seek to communicate with visiting officials such as UN human rights official Hina Jilani in 2007. Even Jakarta-based diplomats face bureaucratic hurdles in attempts to visit West Papua. The U.S. Government maintains that it respects the territorial integrity of the Indonesian state and, on the basis of this policy position, has been reluctant to address the growing human rights crisis in West Papua. At the same time, the U.S. Government and the international community have a responsibility to protect human rights in those circumstances where a local government either will not protect those rights or is complicit in their violation. We call on the U.S. Government and Congress to investigate this clear evidence of human rights abuse in West Papua. The U.S. Government and Congress should also publicly express to the Government of Indonesia in the strongest terms, their opposition to these violations of human rights. We also urge the U.S. Government and Congress, in concert with others in the international community, to press for an internationally facilitated, senior level dialogue between the Indonesian Government and Papuans, including Papuan civil society, to address long-standing Papuan concerns and grievances. These include calls for demilitarization of West Papua, an end to repression of Papuans exercising their human rights and release from detention of those arrested for peaceful dissent, provision of services essential to health and economic security, and Papuan self-determination. Sincerely, John M. Miller National Coordinator, East Timor and Indonesia Action Network (ETAN) Brian Keane Director, Life is Life Ed McWilliams West Papua Advocacy Team cc: Secretary of State Hillary Rodham Clinton Sen. Richard G. Lugar, Ranking Member, Committee on Foreign Relations Committee Rep. Ileana Ros-Lehtinen, Ranking Member, Committee on Foreign Affairs Rep. Eni Faleomavega, chair, Subcommittee on Asia, the Pacific, and the Global Environment Rep. Donald A. Manzullo, Ranking Member, Subcommittee on Asia, the Pacific, and the Global Environment Sen. James Webb, Chair, Subcommittee on East Asian and Pacific Affairs Sen. Johnny Isakson, Ranking Member, Senate Subcommittee on East Asian and Pacific Affairs etanetanetanetaneta netanetanetaneta netanetanetan ETAN welcomes your financial support. Go to http://etan. org/etan/ donate.htm to donate. Thanks. John M. Miller [email protected] National Coordinator East Timor & Indonesia Action Network (ETAN) PO Box 21873, Brooklyn, NY 11202-1873 USA Phone: (718)596-7668 Mobile phone: (917)690-4391 Skype: john.m.miller Web site: http://www.etan. org Send a blank e-mail message to [email protected] to find out how to learn more about East Timor on the Internet etanetanetanetaneta netanetanetaneta netanetanetan [Non-text portions of this message have been removed]
