On Mon, Jan 28, 2013 at 4:19 AM, Michael Van Canneyt <[email protected]> wrote: > Define an iterator type/operator. > > - No interface > - No 'specially named function' in the class. The iterator should be > separate from the class. > Now they promoted 1 function with a special name to a special status: > 'GetEnumerator'
Ah, you mean that FPC's "operator Enumerator" is better? I agree, but the difference is not too great. > All identifiers should be equal for the law :-) I know only two languages with such extreme disdain for reserved words: Forth and, to a lesser extent, Lisp. For example, in Forth, a comment (!) is not a built-in construct, but a word (Forth's analog of procedure) defined in standard library. > Which begs the question why you didn't use a record to begin with. > > I still do not see why the enumerator could not simply return a record > record > key : tkey; > value : tactualtype > end; > > for r in myclass do > begin > Writeln(r.key); > With r.value do > end. the point of my tuples proposal is to do exactly that, with only a single change -- allow to *also* write loop as for key, value in myclass do begin Writeln(key); with value do end; while keeping enumerator the same. > Borland did a world of good for (Object) Pascal, up to Delphi 7. > After that, it went seriously downhill in my opinion; Adding randomly > features without clear direction or regard for the > intent and philosophy of the Pascal language - or so it seems to me. > Like a ship at the mercy of the waves... I would rephrase slightly -- the features they added are, in principle, good ones. However, they hastily (and randomly?) copied them from other languages without a proper adaptation. Take, for example, recently added to FPC array constructors: TIntegerDynArray.Create(1, 2, 3) is much too noisy, and inconsistent with other syntax (it resembles a standard constructor, but takes variable-length argument list, which is impossible for standard constructors). So I would much prefer TIntegerDynArray(1, 2, 3), TIntegerDynArray([1, 2, 3]), or maybe even just [1, 2, 3] if appropriate automatic conversions are defined. -- Alexander S. Klenin _______________________________________________ fpc-devel maillist - [email protected] http://lists.freepascal.org/mailman/listinfo/fpc-devel
