The negativity surrounding the situation at the Ann Arbor Film Festival has
led me to break the silence I’ve maintained since my departure in October
2002 as the Executive Director of the Festival. Though I have not read the
Facebook comments, the petition, nor the letters submitted, I am aware of
the finger pointing and ill will directed at the Festival. I have looked
through the list of letter writers and petition signers and it breaks my
heart that long-standing filmmakers I supported and championed during my
years as Executive Director have turned against the Festival.


Given the situation, I wanted to share a bit of history. As a U/M Film
major and Director of Cinema Guild, a campus film society that co-managed
the AAFF in the 1960’s and ’70’s, I had an operations role with the
Festival. I eventually joined the screening committee, winding up being
connected with the festival for nearly 10 years. I moved away briefly,
ending my involvement. Annette Wilson took over the helm following Director
Ruth Bradley’s 6th season, when Ruth moved to teach film at Ohio University
and to run the Athens Film Festival. After a year as Director, Annette
turned things over to me. The Festival was stagnant; it was down to some 50
entries. Having been involved under George Manupelli’s reign, I knew the
Festival’s reputation and its big picture importance. As Director, I never
deviated from the spirit of the Festival George created. I strongly
believed in it and was committed to nurturing George’s “baby.”


I saw to it that Festival entries grew each year, along with our audiences.
With the help of Rock Ross one year, I learned how to involve the local
community, generating over 100 volunteers who decorated the theater and box
office, housed filmmakers, provided dinners for the screening committee,
donated to the opening night reception, green room and silent auction, and
raised prize monies and awards categories every year by seeking new donors
locally and nationally. By attending other festivals and media conferences
I was able to build the traveling tour from a handful of tour stops to an
entire spring, summer and fall tour, allowing for the work of those
filmmakers included in the tour to be seen by hundreds more viewers. When
Ann Arbor’s Michigan Theater built their screening room, I worked with my
Board of Directors and volunteers to find a way to screen works in both
theaters, creating “Girls Night Out” and genre-specific programs. To ensure
that attendees wouldn’t miss any films, works programmed in the screening
room were included in the main theater programs. Audiences appreciated that
they would not miss even one film in the program of films in competition,
and we gained new audiences who came for genre-specific programs,
especially “Out Night” and animation.


At some point after I left, the Festival’s mission apparently was changed.
Some of the work included in the festival week program were not films
entered into the competition; rather it consisted of work hand-selected by
the Executive Director and/or Program Director. This now meant that
valuable screening time for entered work competed with screening time of
hand-selected works and programs. This is a dramatic shift away from the
Festival mission I upheld: to promote and support experimental and
independent film and to show as much submitted work as time would allow;
every film entered was in competition, regardless of being included in the
Fest week program.


The Festival Annette passed to me was pretty simple: it existed to show new
work and as much of it as possible. The Festival was known for nurturing
filmmakers, which was one of the reasons why they were eager to enter and
be included in the festival week program. I was an effective and popular
director because I reached out to and included the local, SW Michigan and
the larger experimental film community. I developed a relationship with
Canadian Filmmakers Distribution Centre, making it possible for Canadian
experimental filmmakers to ship entries all together from the CFMDC office.
I encouraged filmmakers to attend festival week so they could witness their
works screened on the Michigan Theater’s magnificent screen in front of
large audiences in the theater’s 1700-seat auditorium. I became the voice
of the Festival through local and Detroit media, which dramatically
increased the Festival’s exposure and attendance. The Festival and I were
even featured on Bob Edwards’ NPR “Morning Edition” show in the 1990’s. My
Board of Directors encouraged me to travel to European festivals to seek
out international experimental filmmakers. That’s when the Festival’s
international reach and reputation was born and to say its international
reach and importance only developed in the last ten years negates the
history I experienced first-hand.


I share all of this history because it is frankly shocking to me that in
response to the recent situation at the Festival, some people are
apparently overlooking the years I dedicated myself to the Festival and the
filmmakers, and seem to be creating a “revisionist history.”  Among the
current letter writers are filmmakers whose relationship to the Festival
predates the more recent years in which the Executive Director no longer
viewed all the work and programmed festival week. Makers I championed seem
to have lost sight of and negated what the Festival and I accomplished in
my 15 year Directorship and how the Festival they admired and supported
grew during those years, instead attributing the Festival’s success and
growth in the last decade to a respected programmer. To attribute the
existence of the Festival to these last few years is a negation of the
history of the Festival back to the years George Manupelli, Woody
Sempliner, and Ruth Bradley ran it, up through and including my tenure as
Director. The Festival inherited by Chrisstina Hamilton and all the
Directors following her was built on our hard work and leadership, not
because of the more recent work of one person. Filmmakers whose work
embodied the spirit of the Festival were supported and encouraged years
before this last generation of the Festival.


It’s admirable that people are jumping to the defense of a person, friend,
and programmer they admire, but the emotion stirred by an organizational
change should not be turned against the organization and a philosophy with
a 50+ year history. The Ann Arbor Film Festival is an institution, larger
than any one individual. The AAFF has been made up of hundreds of people
who have been involved as volunteers and staff from its beginning to now.
As in any organization or group, there have always been differing opinions.
However, there’s always been a shared goal within the AAFF. What’s kept the
institution alive is everyone’s dedication and love for the work and for
the makers, plain and simple.


Those of you who seem to be advocating for the end of the Festival, I ask
you: to what end are you doing this? Do you really wish for the country’s
oldest experimental and independent film festival to end? Let’s face it:
experimental film in our culture is already “the other” because of its
non-mainstream nature relative to mainstream dominant cinema. For
filmmakers nurtured by the Festival earlier in their careers to turn
against the Festival and evidently suggest things like “RIP AAFF” is really
sad and pathetic. Loyalty to a respected friend is laudable but there may
be aspects to the situation that you are not privy to either because of
legal restrictions or simply because of the wish to avoid making public the
details of an unpleasant situation. Very few of you know about the inner
workings of the organization and its staff, the day-to-day function or
dysfunction, and the interpersonal relationships. The negative reactions
seem based on selective information, possibly even hearsay. To create such
on-going upheaval is counter-productive to what your goals should be: to
get your work entered, pre-screened and hopefully included in the program,
awarded, and programmed into the traveling tour.


When I left the Festival in 2002, my decision to leave was based on the
fact I recognized some members of my Board of Directors no longer stood
behind me and behind the Festival’s 23-year old by-laws. At that time, I
felt my reason for leaving wasn’t something to share with the public and
Festival supporters because it was nobody’s business but the Board of
Directors and mine. Leaving was a difficult decision for me to make: I
loved my job, I was proud of being able to restore the Festival and build
it into an internationally-recognized event and I most especially adored
working with filmmakers, viewing their films, and curating Festival week.
But I didn’t want a battle, private or public, and I never turned my reason
for leaving into an opportunity to destroy or bad-mouth the Festival or to
give my supporters a reason to direct their emotions at the organization.
The anger now being voiced and spread doesn’t make sense to me. In my
opinion, I had a deeper “axe to grind” when I parted ways with the Festival
but intentionally chose not to go that route because I deeply respected
what the Festival stands for — and still do. Most importantly, I held and
still have the highest regard and respect for the filmmakers who entered
their work.


It pleases me and makes me proud that in the 15 years since I left, the
Festival has grown enormously with considerably increased entries,
financial support and recognition. I wish more than anything for the Ann
Arbor Film Festival to move forward and to continue growing. This adversity
is heartbreaking and entirely counter-productive. Change is a constant.
Leslie Raymond deserves the opportunity to move the Festival forward and to
assure the community at large that the Festival is in good hands, following
the path of past Festival Directors in promoting its mission.


What good does it do to turn against the Festival? We should all be proud
of its history, longevity, the spirit of the original Festival and what it
stands for: inclusivity, not intolerance.


Vicki Honeyman

-- 
Heavenly Metal
M — F 10 - 6  Sat 10 - 3

207 e. ann street
ann arbor mi 48104 usa

heavenlymetal.com
734.663.4247
[email protected]

shop online @
heavenlymetal.com/shop-online
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
tossed salad with vick & mick
wednesdays 6 — 9am on 88.3 fm
wcbn.org  freeform radio
_______________________________________________
FrameWorks mailing list
[email protected]
https://mailman-mail5.webfaction.com/listinfo/frameworks

Reply via email to