On 31/08/06, Paul Saab <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote:
Jeff Rollin ([EMAIL PROTECTED]) wrote:
> If Yahoo (to pick the one big vendor I remember making a big thing of
using
> a BSD) don't reincorporate their changes, perhaps that's because the
license
> allows them not to?
If you think that Yahoo! has not given back to the FreeBSD project,
then you are sorely mistaken. Let me count the ways that Yahoo!
has given back.
As I said, Yahoo are the one big company I remember being cited as using a
BSD. My point was not that "Yahoo does not give back to the FreeBSD
project," but that the BSD licence *allows* them not to give back in a way
that the GPL does not allow (say) Google not to give back to the Linux
project(s).
1. Most of the freebsd cluster resides in a Yahoo! datacenter
2. Up until I left at the end of June, Yahoo had a team of 5 people
working on FreeBSD and we gave back just about everything we were
working on to the project. Now there are 4, but they are doing
incredible work for FreeBSD.
3. NFS locking came from Yahoo!
4. SACK came from Yahoo!
5. Accept filters came from Yahoo!
6. AMD64 port came from Yahoo!
7. IA64 hardware and support came from Yahoo! pushing Intel
8. bce came from Yahoo/Iron port pushing on Broadcom to produce a driver
9. ciss came from Yahoo!
10. bge improvements and fixes came from Yahoo!
11. accept filters came from Yahoo!
12. Numerous private contracts to improve various drivers were funded by
Yahoo!
13. A ton of ATA hardware was sent to sos to make sure drivers were
supported
and yahoo didn't even use most of those controllers.
14. Many other developers got hardware directly from Yahoo!
15. Intel supporting em on FreeBSD came from Yahoo! pressuring Intel
16. minidumps
17. twe/twa support came from Yahoo! pressuring 3ware
I can go on, but my memory gets hazy after 6.5 years of working on
FreeBSD for Yahoo, so before you go bashing Yahoo!, just know that
there are plenty of people doing nothing but FreeBSD work at Yahoo!
We never felt it necessary to actually note that code came from
Yahoo! since most committers know that the code came from Yahoo!
If I were going to bash Yahoo!, I would probably pick some other aspect to
moan about. Like! Those! El Reg! Yahoo! related! Headlines! That! Were!
Funny! At First! But Got! Predictable! After a while!
Jeff.
_______________________________________________
freebsd-chat@freebsd.org mailing list
http://lists.freebsd.org/mailman/listinfo/freebsd-chat
To unsubscribe, send any mail to "[EMAIL PROTECTED]"
