> The main problem with that is: we have no way to keep a valid sum of the
> distfiles if it is autogenerated (in particular with github) and this sum is
> really important.


With github this fortunately is a non-issue. Even though they autogenerate their
tar balls, they keep enough information to make them reproduciable. Just try:

/tmp>fetch https://github.com/Dieterbe/uzbl/tarball/2011.07.25
2011.07.25                                    100% of  143 kB  177 kBps
/tmp>sha256 2011.07.25 
SHA256 (2011.07.25) = 
2e61fa6c62e48d3f13e95a4ea7e7aead65345f6c88a688844ef921685dffe565
/tmp>cat /usr/ports/www/uzbl/distinfo 
SHA256 (uzbl-0.0.0.2011.07.25.tar.gz) = 
2e61fa6c62e48d3f13e95a4ea7e7aead65345f6c88a688844ef921685dffe565
SIZE (uzbl-0.0.0.2011.07.25.tar.gz) = 146851
/tmp>

There still remain some minor issuses, like

* due to autogeneration, you're quite likely to get a http-redirect,
* filenames like 2011.07.25 are not too suitable for a distfile.

But they certainly can be fixed by an appropriate framework. The nice thing is,
github does the autogeneration right.

Best,
Klaus

_______________________________________________
freebsd-ports@freebsd.org mailing list
http://lists.freebsd.org/mailman/listinfo/freebsd-ports
To unsubscribe, send any mail to "freebsd-ports-unsubscr...@freebsd.org"

Reply via email to