Philip Payne wrote:
Thanks to all who replied, lots of food for thought!

Maybe my setup is a little different than what people use because I have different rule sets in /etc/rc.firewall
>>(which is the default with OPEN, SIMPLE and CLIENT)
>>[...]
Good advice against lock-outs though. Is generally the preferred approach to use different files for different
>>rules, rather than keep sets in /etc/rc.firewall?

I usually keep a bunch of ipfw rulesets around in files
named /etc/ipfw.xxxx or /etc/ipf.yyyy and then set my
firewall_type="" (or ipfilter_rules="" to the full path
(it *is* important to use the full path, at least for
ipfw rulesets) when switching among them:

        # ipfw -q /etc/ipfw.open
        # ipfw -q /etc/ipfw.paranoid

>>And if so, how do you set this up in /etc/rc.conf, since
the firewall type by default looks at rc.firewall...

There is a post I made in -questions a while ago that explains all this in a bit of detail. Look at the archives, please..

Right now my ISP is having serious problems and I can't reach
google.com at all, but look at groups.google.com for something
like this:

author:keramidas & group:*freebsd* & ipfw & firewall_type

and you shouldn't have trouble spotting the correct post.

Using the same approach as writing a script to carry out the sh /etc/rc.firewall command.

You could either have different scripts to pass the
> firewall_type variable and then do the firewall rules e.g.:

open-firewall.sh: --- #!/bin/sh FIREWALL_TYPE="OPEN" sh /etc/rc.firewall ---

Nope, that will probably not work...


Capitalization does matter.  It's firewall_type in all lowercase.
Not FIREWALL_TYPE.  But then, even if you get the capitalization
right, rc.firewall will load rc.conf and override this value from
the environment the script runs.

I'm really not a shell scripting person (networking is my area),
> so I can't say this will definitely work but... kind of sounds
> right. Perhaps someone with more shell scripting experise can
> comment.

It'll work fine if rc.conf doesn't override firewall_type :-)

Let me know how you get on. Wouldn't mind knowing for sure what's the
correct approach.

I tried to outline all possible ways of loading rules with the rc.firewall script, without it, manually or whatever in the post mentioned above. Just search the archives. I can't help you with the searching ATM :-/

- Giorgos


_______________________________________________ [EMAIL PROTECTED] mailing list http://lists.freebsd.org/mailman/listinfo/freebsd-questions To unsubscribe, send any mail to "[EMAIL PROTECTED]"

Reply via email to