On 6/15/2026 7:23 PM, Thomas Desi via Freedos-user wrote:
Why does the size of the command line matter when you're doing a redirect of 
output?

It redirects the input to a file using standard redirection, it would be just 
like reading a file from a com port, which used to be done all the time in the 
early dos days, and files considerably larger than 127 bytes were certainly 
transferable using that method, so redirecting the keyboard to a file (which is 
what you're doing when using the copy con) should perform the same redirect, 
and the size of the command line should have no bearing on the size of the file.

perhaps buffers and/or memory sizes may impact the size of the file, but I have 
no idea why the command line would make any difference.

sounds intrigueing - sorry my ignorance, could you give a practical example for 
the method you would actually input the text?  I have no problem with the file 
size (APPEND adds more and more to my  foo.txt file).

when you say:
It redirects the input to a file using standard redirection, it would be just 
like reading a file from a com port,
I guess that the „input“ still IS limited to chunks of max 127 characters, 
right?  I would need some kind of „buffer“ to fill until I would APPEND that 
buffer to a file, i.e. writing it on disk.

Or am I missing another trick her?

I don't actually know how large a buffer you get when using redirects, but considering I used to print files all the time with a simple copy file.txt>prn

(which is basically the same thing you're doing here), the printer didn't care how large the file was.  I'm sure there's some buffering is beeind done, and where or how large those buffers are I don't know, but, I'm fairly confident they aren't reliant on command line length to determine how much can be transferred, but even if they are, it wouldn't matter, because your disk drive is fast enough that it will remove characters from the resident buffer before it becomes a problem.


If you want a sample to test this, simply create a file via copy con>>out.txt

then just type 1234567890

13 times or more, and when you press ctrl-Z to close the redirect, it will create your file, and if it's more than 128 bites, then you know it worked.




_______________________________________________
Freedos-user mailing list
[email protected]
https://lists.sourceforge.net/lists/listinfo/freedos-user

Reply via email to