Sorry for the late response. :)


Dirk Meyer wrote:
OK, I can now reproduce it. Rob, you won't like it.

You are correct!


The libdvdread in the runtime detects a libdecss in the system
(good). But they are compiled on different systems and are _not_
compatible. We need your css lib on your system to match it.

That's NOT good.


So what to do now? If we remove the libdvdread from the runtime,
Freevo can't play dvds anymore (bad), right now it crashes (even
worse). The only solution is to use the css lib matching the
dvdread. But including decss will be a legal problem.

Right, we can't include decss.


So basicly we need to expand the runtime: you say where to download
the decss needed. The runtime checks if it's there and activated all
dvd stuff, if not it's deactivated. A different solution would be to
build runtimes for each distro. Both are no good ideas, so what do
other people think?

If we get the runtime to say where do download decss it will have to get the same one I am using (or the builder of the runtime), put it in runtime/dll/ and append it to runtime/preloads, then restart Freevo. This would be a pain in the ass to get working and support so you won't see me working on that (kinda where I'm going to draw the line wrt me and the runtime).


I'm not sure what I think about building a runtime for each distro... I can build one for Debian Sid! That's not a perfect solution either I guess, it undermines the whole purpose of the runtime - one package to work on all platforms.

Krister: that's why I don't like the runtime

Sometimes it seems to cause more trouble that it's worth but its important especially for newbies.


Maybe we should focus on package availability and instructions to install deps properly under each mainstream distro. In the meantime we could include your modified dvdinfo.py in the runtime and not worry about it too much. If people have problems with the runtime they can install things the "right way".

-Rob



-------------------------------------------------------
This SF.net email is sponsored by: SF.net Giveback Program.
Does SourceForge.net help you be more productive?  Does it
help you create better code?  SHARE THE LOVE, and help us help
YOU!  Click Here: http://sourceforge.net/donate/
_______________________________________________
Freevo-users mailing list
[EMAIL PROTECTED]
https://lists.sourceforge.net/lists/listinfo/freevo-users

Reply via email to