B.C. First Nations divided over Enbridge pipeline
The Canadian Press
Updated: Sat. Dec. 3
2011 8:53 PM ET
Members of a British Columbia First Nation where hereditary chiefs have voiced
support for the Northern Gateway pipeline appear split over the controversial
project.
On Friday, a group of hereditary chiefs from the Gitxsan in northwestern B.C.
announced it had accepted Enbridge Inc.'s (TSX:ENB) offer of an equity stake
in the $5.5-billion project.
In announcing the agreement, Chief Elmer Derrick heralded his community's
"trusted" relationship with Enbridge, and he estimated the deal would be worth
at least $7 million for the Gitxsan.
But shortly after the announcement, a group claiming to represent other
hereditary chiefs, including Geri McDougall, and four Gitxsan bands issued a
news release denouncing the agreement.
The news release came from the plaintiffs in a lawsuit against the Gitxsan
Treaty Society and the B.C. Treaty Commission over complaints about ongoing
treaty negotiations with the federal and provincial governments.
The release said members of the Gitxsan nation weren't consulted about the
Northern Gateway agreement, and argued it was wrong to sign a deal before the
environmental impact assessment process is finished.
"Elmer Derrick and the Gitxsan Treaty Society/Gitxsan Economic Development
Corp. does not speak for all Gitxsan," the news release said.
"The representatives say that Mr. Derrick has embarrassed and shamed the
Gitxsan people by undermining the 61 First Nations who are opposed to the
project. The representatives say, 'We stand in solidarity to those opposing
it."'
The 33,000-square-kilometre Gitxsan territory sits north of Northern Gateway's
proposed route, but the line would cross six streams that feed into a lake
the First Nation relies on for fishing.
The 1,200-kilometre Northern Gateway pipeline proposal, which would bring
diluted bitumen from Alberta's oil sands to the B.C. coast, has been the
source of considerable controversy among First Nations communities and
environmental groups.
Enbridge has offered equity stake agreements to 50 First Nations groups,
although the Gitxsan was the first the sign. The company claims a number of
other communities are prepared to sign, but hasn't said which ones or when
that would happen.
Other aboriginal communities have been fiercely critical of the pipeline,
vowing to take legal action to stop it. Currently, 61 First Nations
communities have signed the Save the Fraser Declaration against the pipeline.
A federal review panel is preparing to hold public hearings into the pipeline
project early in the new year.
The provincial and federal governments have both been strong proponents of the
project, particularly as political controversy in the United States delays
TransCanada Corp.'s (TSX:TRP) Keystone XL line.
The U.S. State Department has effectively delayed the Keystone XL until early
2013 -- after the next presidential election -- by ordering TransCanada to
come up with a new route through Nebraska to avoid an important source of
water.
