Greetings,

        I am currently trying to set up a VPN between my location and a
remote vendor.  I have set up the following rules:

MySVR   (NATed Address) Internal: 172.x.y.z  External: 209.x.y.z
MyFW                        209.x.y.2
MyEncryptionDomain (Group) Net_172 and Net_209
TheirSVR (NATed Address) Internal: 172.16.x.y External: 12.x.y.z
TheirFW             12.x.y.2
TheirEncryptionDomain (Group) Net_172_16 and Net_12

RuleBase
Source          Dest                    Service         Action
MySVR,MyFW              TheirFW,TheirSVR  ICMP                  Encrypt
TheirFW,TheirSVR        MySVR, MyFW             ICMP
Encrypt

The encryption scheme I am using on both sides is ISAKMP/OAKLEY, 3DES+MD5
ESP, shared-secret
I am able to encrypt fine on both ends and the key installs fine, but on the
receiving Firewall end, the keys install fine but I get a drop with the Info
message of 

        icmp-type 8 icmp-code 0 encryption failure: Peer used wrong methods
scheme: ISAKMP

Sometimes I get the following message as well

        icmp-type 8 icmp-code 0 encryption failure: no response from peer.
scheme: ISAKMP

I have verified that both MyServer and TheirServer can be accessed from
external sources (telnet to route-server.ip.att.net and traceroute/ping to
both machines successful)

Anyone have any helpful tips or advice, maybe had a similar problem?


================================================================================
     To unsubscribe from this mailing list, please see the instructions at
               http://www.checkpoint.com/services/mailing.html
================================================================================

Reply via email to