On 29 January 2018 at 11:08, 'Federico Pareschi' via ganeti-devel <
[email protected]> wrote:
> Sorry, this email had completely flown under my radar.
>
No worries.
The issues have all been migrated to the github repository, however there
> is a difference between 'fixed' and 'released' in the old issue tracker on
> code.google.com. By importing these issues in github, these states turned
> into tags. I assume 'released' meant the issue could be closed, but 'fixed'
> simply added the tag but the issue stayed open.
>
Sorry, not sure I understand here. Do I read that code.google.com had two
"fixed" state - one fix committed ("fixed"), and one fix committed and also
released ("released")? If so, and if Github only has fixed, I propose to
drop the released state.
I had been thinking about going through all of them and closing the ones
> marked as fixed but I wanted to review them first and is a lot of
> time/effort that I haven't invested yet (verifying the fix + closing the
> issue rather than just automatically closing all of them).
>
I would suggest to simply fix all of them, based on:
- we should trust the code.google.com "fixed" tag;
- there are a lot of very old issues that are for sure fixed, and verifying
all of them is time better spent on fixing new issues
If some issue is still open, and if users still hit it, let's crowdsource
the effort of reopening (against current versions) to the users :)
iustin
On Fri, 26 Jan 2018 at 19:53, Iustin Pop <[email protected]> wrote:
>
>> On 2018-01-14 02:15:41, Iustin Pop wrote:
>> > Hi all,
>> >
>> > I did a quick look at the GitHub issue tracker today, and it seems that
>> > the migrator did not close the migrated issues that were closed.
>> >
>> > More specifically, a search of:
>> >
>> > is:issue is:open label:Status:Fixed
>> >
>> > Shows 98 such open issues. If I'm not mistaken, "Status:Fixed" is a
>> > googlecode imported label, which tells me that the migrator had some
>> > issue (ha) importing the bug list.
>>
>> Friendly ping? Mostly for my own curiosity.
>>
>> iustin
>>
>
