> > 1) Set TREE_THIS_NOTRAP on the INDIRECT_REF built for VLA decls. This > > is correct since stack memory isn't considered as trapping in the IL. > > This is ok.
Thanks. > > 2) Improve gimplification of complex conditions in COND_EXPR. They are > > naturally generated by the Ada compiler and the patch avoids emitting > > redundant branches in GIMPLE, visible at -O0 for the testcase: > > Shouldn't > > + /* Remove any COMPOUND_EXPR so the following cases will be caught. */ > + STRIP_TYPE_NOPS (TREE_OPERAND (expr, 0)); > + if (TREE_CODE (TREE_OPERAND (expr, 0)) == COMPOUND_EXPR) > + gimplify_compound_expr (&TREE_OPERAND (expr, 0), pre_p, true); > > happen in gimple_boolify instead so that other callers also benefit? > That is, add a COMPOUND_EXPR case there? Not clear to me. gimple_boolify doesn't gimplify, it boolifies, i.e. only does type conversions to boolean. This looks orthogonal. > So, what does the GENERIC look like here? Attached. Barely readable, like pretty much all GENERIC for Ada, but you can see the big IF statement with the COMPOUND_EXPR on the RHS of the &&. -- Eric Botcazou
P (const boolean b, struct s1, struct s2) { SAVE_EXPR <s2.P_BOUNDS->LB0>; SAVE_EXPR <s2.P_BOUNDS->UB0>; SAVE_EXPR <SAVE_EXPR <s2.P_BOUNDS->UB0> >= SAVE_EXPR <s2.P_BOUNDS->LB0> ? (SAVE_EXPR <s2.P_BOUNDS->UB0> - SAVE_EXPR <s2.P_BOUNDS->LB0>) + 1 : 0>; SAVE_EXPR <s1.P_BOUNDS->LB0>; SAVE_EXPR <s1.P_BOUNDS->UB0>; SAVE_EXPR <SAVE_EXPR <s1.P_BOUNDS->UB0> >= SAVE_EXPR <s1.P_BOUNDS->LB0> ? (SAVE_EXPR <s1.P_BOUNDS->UB0> - SAVE_EXPR <s1.P_BOUNDS->LB0>) + 1 : 0>; { typedef p__TS2bP1___XD p__TS2bP1___XD; typedef <unnamed-signed:64> struct <unnamed-signed:64>; typedef character p__S2b[(size_type) SAVE_EXPR <s2.P_BOUNDS->LB0>:SAVE_EXPR <s2.P_BOUNDS->UB0> >= SAVE_EXPR <s2.P_BOUNDS->LB0> ? (size_type) SAVE_EXPR <s2.P_BOUNDS->UB0> : (size_type) SAVE_EXPR <s2.P_BOUNDS->LB0> + -1]; typedef p__TS1bP1___XD p__TS1bP1___XD; typedef <unnamed-signed:64> struct <unnamed-signed:64>; typedef character p__S1b[(size_type) SAVE_EXPR <s1.P_BOUNDS->LB0>:SAVE_EXPR <s1.P_BOUNDS->UB0> >= SAVE_EXPR <s1.P_BOUNDS->LB0> ? (size_type) SAVE_EXPR <s1.P_BOUNDS->UB0> : (size_type) SAVE_EXPR <s1.P_BOUNDS->LB0> + -1]; const integer L3b = (const integer) (SAVE_EXPR <SAVE_EXPR <s1.P_BOUNDS->UB0> >= SAVE_EXPR <s1.P_BOUNDS->LB0> ? (SAVE_EXPR <s1.P_BOUNDS->UB0> - SAVE_EXPR <s1.P_BOUNDS->LB0>) + 1 : 0>); const integer L4b = (const integer) (SAVE_EXPR <SAVE_EXPR <s2.P_BOUNDS->UB0> >= SAVE_EXPR <s2.P_BOUNDS->LB0> ? (SAVE_EXPR <s2.P_BOUNDS->UB0> - SAVE_EXPR <s2.P_BOUNDS->LB0>) + 1 : 0>); const integer L5b = (const integer) ((integer) L3b + (integer) L4b); const integer L6b = (integer) L3b != 0 ? (const integer) SAVE_EXPR <s1.P_BOUNDS->LB0> : (const integer) SAVE_EXPR <s2.P_BOUNDS->LB0>; const integer R8b = (integer) L5b == 0 ? (const integer) SAVE_EXPR <s2.P_BOUNDS->UB0> : (const integer) (((integer) L5b + -1) + (integer) L6b); typedef p__TTS7bSP1___XD p__TTS7bSP1___XD; typedef <unnamed-signed:64> struct <unnamed-signed:64>; typedef character p__TS7bS[(size_type) L6b:(integer) R8b >= (integer) L6b ? (size_type) R8b : (size_type) L6b + -1]; character S7b[(size_type) L6b:(integer) R8b >= (integer) L6b ? (size_type) R8b : (size_type) L6b + -1]; typedef <unnamed-signed:64> struct <unnamed-signed:64>; typedef character p__T9b[1:4]; typedef p__TS2bP1___XD p__TS2bP1___XD; typedef <unnamed-signed:64> struct <unnamed-signed:64>; typedef character p__S2b[(size_type) SAVE_EXPR <s2.P_BOUNDS->LB0>:SAVE_EXPR <s2.P_BOUNDS->UB0> >= SAVE_EXPR <s2.P_BOUNDS->LB0> ? (size_type) SAVE_EXPR <s2.P_BOUNDS->UB0> : (size_type) SAVE_EXPR <s2.P_BOUNDS->LB0> + -1]; typedef p__TS1bP1___XD p__TS1bP1___XD; typedef <unnamed-signed:64> struct <unnamed-signed:64>; typedef character p__S1b[(size_type) SAVE_EXPR <s1.P_BOUNDS->LB0>:SAVE_EXPR <s1.P_BOUNDS->UB0> >= SAVE_EXPR <s1.P_BOUNDS->LB0> ? (size_type) SAVE_EXPR <s1.P_BOUNDS->UB0> : (size_type) SAVE_EXPR <s1.P_BOUNDS->LB0> + -1]; typedef <unnamed-signed:64> struct <unnamed-signed:64>; typedef character p__T9b[1:4]; if ((boolean) b && (SAVE_EXPR < const integer L3b = (const integer) (SAVE_EXPR <SAVE_EXPR <s1.P_BOUNDS->UB0> >= SAVE_EXPR <s1.P_BOUNDS->LB0> ? (SAVE_EXPR <s1.P_BOUNDS->UB0> - SAVE_EXPR <s1.P_BOUNDS->LB0>) + 1 : 0>); const integer L4b = (const integer) (SAVE_EXPR <SAVE_EXPR <s2.P_BOUNDS->UB0> >= SAVE_EXPR <s2.P_BOUNDS->LB0> ? (SAVE_EXPR <s2.P_BOUNDS->UB0> - SAVE_EXPR <s2.P_BOUNDS->LB0>) + 1 : 0>); const integer L5b = (const integer) ((integer) L3b + (integer) L4b); const integer L6b = (integer) L3b != 0 ? (const integer) SAVE_EXPR <s1.P_BOUNDS->LB0> : (const integer) SAVE_EXPR <s2.P_BOUNDS->LB0>; const integer R8b = (integer) L5b == 0 ? (const integer) SAVE_EXPR <s2.P_BOUNDS->UB0> : (const integer) (((integer) L5b + -1) + (integer) L6b); typedef p__TTS7bSP1___XD p__TTS7bSP1___XD; typedef <unnamed-signed:64> struct <unnamed-signed:64>; typedef character p__TS7bS[(size_type) L6b:(integer) R8b >= (integer) L6b ? (size_type) R8b : (size_type) L6b + -1]; character S7b[(size_type) L6b:(integer) R8b >= (integer) L6b ? (size_type) R8b : (size_type) L6b + -1]; system.concat_2.str_concat_2 ({.P_ARRAY=(character[(size_type) <PLACEHOLDER_EXPR struct >.P_BOUNDS->LB0:<PLACEHOLDER_EXPR struct >.P_BOUNDS->UB0 >= <PLACEHOLDER_EXPR struct >.P_BOUNDS->LB0 ? (size_type) <PLACEHOLDER_EXPR struct >.P_BOUNDS->UB0 : (size_type) <PLACEHOLDER_EXPR struct >.P_BOUNDS->LB0 + -1] *) &S7b, .P_BOUNDS=&{.LB0=(integer) L6b, .UB0=(integer) R8b}}, s1, s2);>;, (integer) R8b - (integer) L6b == 3 && VIEW_CONVERT_EXPR<character[1:4]>(S7b) == "toto";)) { .gnat_rcheck_21 ("p.adb", 4); } else { } return; } _GLOBAL.SZ0.ada_p (integer p0, integer p1) { return p1 <= p0 ? (bit_size_type) ((((size_type) p0 - (size_type) p1) + 1) * 8) : 0; _GLOBAL.SZ1.ada_p (integer p0, integer p1) { return p1 <= p0 ? ((size_type) p0 - (size_type) p1) + 1 : 0;