Greetings! root <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> writes:
> well, the build is proceeding and appears to be progressing ok. > of course i have no idea WHY it works since there are no comments > in the patch file. i'll test the graphics and hyperdoc in the morning. > My apologies, Tim! This is that same stuff I tried to document when I was in your office last spring, and I think once on the list. But the general idea is that one can run ld (the linker used by gcc et.al.) now from within gcl, so C libraries and objects can be incorporated. One can even avoid compiling C source explicitly via command line gcc by wrapping same in #'clines and using #'compile from within GCL. The only advantage here is to avoid patch rot against GCL source makefiles, and to allow for the time saving ability to use a pre-compiled GCL with the source tree no longer available. > so code appears in debian > with changes that are not in the master source tree > and is distributed under the name 'axiom' > and you don't consider that a fork.... Please let me clarify here, not that I feel you you are expressing alarm over this situation, but all Debian source trees have some build modifications/patches perforce to enable the package to comply with Debian policy. A well designed package simply adds a debian subdirectory with a few essential installation scripts, and a wrapper makefile (called debian/rules) to provide the targets used by the autobuilders. Occasionally a patch to the upstream source will be included, and again in well-designed cases, this is supplied in the debian subdirectory and only applied when making the targets of debian/rules, -- i.e. the freshly unpacked source tree is 'pristine'. I made the decision to build the Debian packages against the pre-supplied gcl package not in an attempt to interfere with the judgment or design goals of axiom, but rather simply as a practical measure -- many of our autobuilders are very slow, and gcl is compiled (and ansi-tested) on all of them already, and used by maxima and acl2, so it really was a resource saver to enable axiom to be shipped on all 12 Debian platforms. > > but patching the original source files of gcl and noweb > to build axiom (but not a gcl or noweb distro) > is considered a fork? > > methinks you're being a bit harsh. forking is not intended > in either case and i'd never claim camm is trying to fork > axiom. we've had close cooperation over many years he's > remotely logged onto my main laptop to debug the original > SELinux failure and we worked together to corner an issue > of semantics that was killing the axiom compiler. i have > the greatest respect for him and wouldn't consider forking > gcl under any circumstances. > And please let me say that I never thought otherwise. I am more than happy for Tim and anyone else to use the GCL source tree as they see fit (other than to close it of course). And the respect is mutual! I would just suggest that as a member of the axiom team, we always consider ways to increase the modularization of the code, as it should be a time saver for us in the long run. To this end, if there is ever anything axiom needs in GCL proper, please let me know and I will try to provide it. I've made some attempts in this regard in the past, though they are likely inadequate. > the fact that debian changes are not integrated into the > axiom source tree is likely due to miscommunication and > lack of time or lack of understanding, not malicious intent. > this needs to be fixed, though, as the debian version should > be buildable from the master sources. i was under the impression > that they were. I believe that the 'external gcl' model was used by the BSD people too. If it is deemed desirable, perhaps we could supply an external_gcl or some such target in the makefile and avoid interfering with your preferred method. Take care, > > sending (or resending) patch files that fix the differences > is usually sufficient. > > if you'll push the noweb changes all the way thru the build > process and send patch files i'll 'fix' that also. > > t > > > > > > -- Camm Maguire [EMAIL PROTECTED] ========================================================================== "The earth is but one country, and mankind its citizens." -- Baha'u'llah _______________________________________________ Gcl-devel mailing list [email protected] http://lists.gnu.org/mailman/listinfo/gcl-devel
