Hi Sharon,
--On 16.01.07 11:38 -0500 Tom-PT Taylor wrote:
This was formulated for generality. In a pure firewall, no reservations occur
or are needed, but the semantics were defined so that the invoker doesn't need
to know the configuration of the middlebox.
Chisholm, Sharon (CAR:ZZ00) wrote:
Hi
The text shows up in a number of requests
For example, in the terminology section, there is the following definition
"policy reserve rule A policy rule containing a reserve action.
The policy condition of this rule is
always true. The action is the
reservation of just an IP address or a
combination of an IP address and a range
of port numbers on neither side, one side,
or both sides of the middlebox, depending
on the middlebox configuration."
On a NAT this transaction reserves resources.
On firewalls no resources are allocated by this transaction.
Still, it is useful implementing this transaction on a firewall,
as pointed out in section 2.3.1:
Some cases require knowing in advance which IP address (and port
number) would be chosen by NAT in a PER transaction. This
information is required before sufficient information for performing
a complete PER transaction is available (see example in section 4.2).
For supporting such cases, the core transactions are extended by the
Policy Reserve Rule (PRR) transaction serving for
- reserving addresses and port numbers at NATs (PRR)
the information that is returned by the middlebox is the IP address
that is externally used for the communication specified in the request.
Even though the reply from a pure firewall is obvious (in the absence
of address translation, the external IP address is the same address as
the internal address of the communication end point), it may make sense
to implement it, because then the client may use the same procedure for
both kinds of middleboxes (firewalls and NATS).
Thanks,
Juergen
Sharon
-----Original Message-----
From: Martin Stiemerling [mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED]
Sent: Tuesday, January 16, 2007 11:00 AM
To: Chisholm, Sharon (CAR:ZZ00)
Cc: [email protected]; Taylor, Tom-PT (CAR:AR00); Melinda
Shore; Magnus Westerlund; Jürgen Quittek
Subject: Re: Generate Review of RFC 3989 as Proposed Standard
Hi Sharon,
Thank you very much for the review.
It looks like we can quickly fix issues 2 to 8 by adding
appropriate clarifications.
But we have a question on issue No.1:
1. I didn't find where it was explained the reasoning behind being
able to send a request that reserves stuff on neither side of the
middlebox.
It would seem a waste of processing.
Which request are you referring to?
Thanks,
Jürgen and Martin
--
Juergen Quittek [EMAIL PROTECTED] Tel: +49 6221 4342-115
NEC Europe Ltd., Network Laboratories Fax: +49 6221 4342-155
Kurfuersten-Anlage 36, 69115 Heidelberg, Germany http://www.netlab.nec.de
_______________________________________________
Gen-art mailing list
[email protected]
https://www1.ietf.org/mailman/listinfo/gen-art