On Thu, Oct 21, 2010 at 3:30 PM, Jakob Homan <jho...@yahoo-inc.com> wrote: >> It's worth double checking. When we added the YDH patch set to CDH3 >> we ran a script to see which patches were in YDH but not yet in trunk >> and it turned up around 100 or so patches. > > If the patch was just checking 1:1 Jira to patch, it would certainly not > work. We were uploading multiple patches to the same JIRA to avoid opening > extraneous issues before generating patches for trunk. Venerable old > HDFS-1150, for instance, went through about different patches applied to > Y!'s branch before the final version.
That's what I meant by saying "a fair number of those may have been included in trunk but under a different jira". There seemed to be a number of patches that are not in trunk under any jira (eg MR-1088, MR-1100 where the jira is still open). We need to go through the patches in YDH and CDH and get them reviewed and checked in. Thanks, Eli > -jg > > > Eli Collins wrote: >> >> On Thu, Oct 21, 2010 at 1:00 PM, Owen O'Malley <omal...@apache.org> wrote: >>> >>> On Oct 21, 2010, at 12:13 PM, Ian Holsman wrote: >>> >>>> I wanted to start a conversation about how we could merge the the >>>> cloudera >>>> + >>>> yahoo distribtutions of hadoop into our codebase, >>>> and what would be required. >>> >>> All of the patches that are the "yahoo distribution of hadoop" have been >>> in >>> Apache's trunk for months. >> > fair number of those may >> >> have been included in trunk but under a different jira, however some >> (eg MR-1088, MR-1100) are definitely not in trunk. Also, if I >> remember correctly some of the 20-based patches are substantially >> different than the versions for trunk. >> >> Thanks, >> Eli > >
