+1 Arun
On Jul 11, 2011, at 5:11 PM, Jakob Homan wrote: > As discussed in the recent thread on HDFS-1623 branching models, I'd > like to amend the bylaws to provide that branches should get a minimum > of three committer +1s before being merged to trunk. > > The rationale: > Feature branches are often created in order that developers can > iterate quickly without the review then commit requirements of trunk. > Branches' commit requirements are determined by the branch maintainer > and in this situation are often set up as commit-then-review. As > such, there is no way to guarantee that the entire changeset offered > for trunk merge has had a second pair of eyes on it. Therefore, it is > prudent to give that final merge heightened scrutiny, particularly > since these branches often extensively affect critical parts of the > system. Requiring three binding +1s does not slow down the branch > development process, but does provide a better chance of catching bugs > before they make their way to trunk. > > Specifically, under the Actions subsection, this vote would add a new > bullet item: > * Branch merge: A feature branch that does not require the same > criteria for code to be committed to trunk will require three binding > +1s before being merged into trunk. > > The last bylaw change required lazy majority of PMC and ran for 7 > days, which I believe would apply to this one as well. That would > have this vote ending 5pm PST July 18. > -Jakob