As long as the project has enough PPMC members for overseeing the podling and moving forward to clear graduation tasks, I'm glad to see its graduation.
I have known Livy from the very beginning. And I have observed that this project has suffered from a lack of maintenance due to the original authors' waning interest. However, since then, users have stepped up to take over the community. I believe this is an excellent example of how Apache, as a vendor-neutral foundation, can ensure a project's continuity even after a single vendor loses interest. Therefore, if the project meets the graduation requirements, I would be very happy to see it graduate smoothly. Best, tison. Jean-Baptiste Onofré <[email protected]> 于2026年4月29日周三 19:59写道： > Hi everyone, > > Thanks to the community's support, Livy currently has great momentum and > sustainable activity. > > The project has completed several releases, most recently 0.9.0-incubating > in January, and preparations for 0.10.0 are already underway. Notably, the > project has handled security issues efficiently, including CVE-2025-66249 > and CVE-2025-60012 in the latest release. > > While Livy has been in incubation since 2017, the project is mature and the > community is planning further improvements and features. Although the > community is quiet, it remains solid. I have discussed adding new > committers and PMC members with several PPMC members. We agree that > graduation would encourage new contributions, and the project is eager to > welcome new members. > > The PPMC is active and maintains clean governance according to the Apache > Way, including brand protection and the management of security reports and > releases. I am confident that the project and its community are sustainable > for the long term. > > What are your thoughts? > > Regards, > JB >
