David Jencks wrote:
-1
scm info is wrong (should end in "trunk")
depends on unreleased parent pom. I'd have no problem voting on both
poms together.
Thanks, that's good advise.
So, Vivek: for the next VOTE you might want to make it a combined one so you don't have to wait until the vote for the parent pom has been
accepted.
versions are not specified for maven-clean-plugin and
maven-compiler-plugin. Are they specified elsewhere?
Since the minimum maven version is specified to be 2.0.9, and maven-2.0.9 actually "pins" these versions, effectively this means these
plugins do have an effective/enforced version (maven-clean-plugin-2.2, maven-compiler-plugin-2.0.2).
But specifying (those) versions for these won't harm of course.
Since including non-java files in src/main/java and src/test/java is
very bad practice I would prefer to not support it and force any project
that does wish to do this to muck up its own pom rather than promoting
it with the resource settings in the root pom. However this is not
enough for a -1.
Oh, I really overlooked those.
I agree the build/resources and build/testResources elements should not be
included in such a master pom.
I propose those element simply to be removed.
In addition, I think the eclipse-plugin also is a bit too specific for a master
pom and maybe should be dropped as well?
As with the portals-pom I'd prefer to see the "review copy" in a nexus
staging repo and the actual artifact being voted on in a svn tag.
Thanks again for pointing this out.
Now only where to find proper and currrent guidelines/docs for how to apply the
nexus release procedures...
Regards,
Ate
thanks
david jencks
On Mar 17, 2009, at 9:23 AM, Randy Watler wrote:
+1
Vivek Kumar wrote:
Hi,
As with the earlier proposed release of the portal-pom for the
portals project, we also propose to release an applications-pom for the
applications project.
I'd like to make a release of this parent POM so that we can start
referring to a non-SNAPSHOT version,
applications pom is available here for review
http://svn.apache.org/viewvc/portals/applications/applications-pom/trunk/pom.xml?view=markup
Please vote on releasing this version 1.0 of Applications-pom
POM. The vote is open for the next 72 hours.
[ ] +1 for Release
[ ] -1 Don't release, reason
Here's my +1.
Vivek Kumar
