Dear Wiki user, You have subscribed to a wiki page or wiki category on "Ws Wiki" for change notification.
The following page has been changed by SimonLaws: http://wiki.apache.org/ws/Tuscany/Interop ------------------------------------------------------------------------------ * Move an entire SDO from one implementation to another - session persistance, generic messaging, data integration * Exchange change summary between implementations - third party data editing - == Features (from interop p.o.v) == + == IO Features (from interop p.o.v) == + ||'''Feature''' || '''Java''' || '''C++''' || '''PHP''' || + || XML (DAS) || Y || Y || Y || + || RDB DAS || Y || N || Y || + || Serialize to session || ? || N || via serialize() || + || Serialize to WS || Y (1) || Y (1) || N || + + (1) - SDO->XMLHelper->String->Axiom + + + == Test Summery == - || '''Feature''' || '''Java''' || '''C++''' || '''PHP''' || '''Series''' || '''Who''' || || '''Note''' || + || # ||'''Test''' || '''Java''' || '''C++''' || '''PHP''' || '''Who''' || '''Note''' || - || 1 XML DAS/Helper Serialization || Y || Y || Y || 1 || SL || Interop via file system write and read || + || 1 ||XML->SDO-XML || Y || Y || Y || SL || Interop via file system write and read || + || 2 ||XML->SDO->AddData->XML - Dynamic || Y || Y || Y || SL || Java change summary reimplementation about to start || + || 3 ||XML->SDO->AddData->XML - Generated || Y || Not Supported || Y (By Name/By Index) || TBD || PHP support is already used in test 2 || + || 4 ||XSD->SDO-XSD || Y || Y || Not Supported || SL || Interop via file system write and read || - || ....1.1 Instance (XML) || Y || Y || Y || 1 || SL || || - || ....1.2 Change summary (XMI?) || Y || Y || Y || 6 || TBD || Level of support to be determined, Reimplementation in java about to start || - || ........1.2.1 Dynamic || Y || Y || Y || 6 || TBD || || - || ........1.2.2 Generated || Y || Not Supported || Y (By Name/By Index) || 6 || TBD || || - || ....1.3Model (XSD) || Y || Y || Y || 2 || SL/KG || || - || 2 SDO Serialization || ? || ? || Stores SDO state in session || 5 || SL || Instance, model and change summary all together (XML?). Level of support in Java/C++ to be determined. Is this different from XMLHelper/DAS function || - || 3 Axiom Serialization || Y || Not Yet || Not Supported || 4 || || || - || ....3.1 From XML to Axiom || Y || Not Yet || Not Supported || 4 || || - || ....3.2 From Axiom to XML || Y || Not Yet || Not Supported || 4 || || - || 4 RDB DAS || Y || Not Supported ||Y || 3 || SL || Interop via relational database write and read || + || 5 ||RDB->SDO->RDB|| Y || Not Supported ||Y || SL || Interop via relational database write and read || - || ....4.1 Instance (XML) || Y || Not Supported || Y || 3 || SL || || - || ....4.2 Change summary (XMI?) || Y || Not Supported || Y || 7 || TBD || || - || ........4.2.1 Dynamic || Y || Not Supported || Y || 7 || TBD || || - || ........4.2.2 Generated || Y || Not Supported || Y (By Name/By Index) || 7 || TBD || || + || 6 ||RDB->SDO->AddData->RDB - Dynamic|| Y || Not Supported || Y || SL || Interop via database write and read || || + || 7 ||RDB->SDO->AddData->RDB - Generated || Y || Not Supported || Y || SL || PHP generation support is already used in test 6 || + || 8 ||XML->SDO->Axiom->SOAP->Axiom->SDO->XML || Y || Y || Not Supported || AB || || + || 9 || XML->SDO->Session->SDO->XML || ? || N || Stores SDO state in PHP session || SL || Instance, model and change summary all together (XML?). Level of support in Java/C++ to be determined. Is this different from XMLHelper/DAS function? || - == Series 1 - Reading and writing XML files in Java/C++/PHP and comparing output == + == Test 1 - Reading and writing XML files in Java/C++/PHP and comparing output == === Schema Feature === Spec version 2.0.1 features. @@ -174, +178 @@ *Adds xsi:type to top level element *Removes schema location attribtute + == Test 2 - As test 1 but with data added in SDO through dynamic interface == + + == Test 3 - As test 1 but with data added in SDO through generated interface == + + No generated interface in C++ yet + - == Series 2 - Reading and writing XSD files from Java/C++/PHP and comparing output == + == Test 4 - Reading and writing XSD files from Java/C++/PHP and comparing output == - Using the schema from Series 1 have the SDO implementations create a schema based on type meta-data. The following tables record only issues. For types from the series 1 schema that present no problem no entry is included. + Using the schema from test1 have the SDO implementations create a schema based on type meta-data. The following tables record only issues. For types from the series 1 schema that present no problem no entry is included. || '''Feature''' || '''Schema''' || '''Java M1''' || '''C++ SVN''' || '''PHP R1.0.1''' || '''Note''' || || || interop1.xsd || Schema generation not supported || || Only supported via Serialize() || || - - - == Series 3 - Reading and wirting RDBMS tables and comparing result == + == Test 5 - Reading and writing RDBMS tables and comparing result == + == Test 6 - As test 5 but with data added in SDO through dynamic interface == + + == Test 7 - As test 5 but with data added in SDO through generated interface == + - == Series 4 - Passing messages via Apache Axis == + == Test 8 - Passing messages via Apache Axis2 == In due course both Java and C++ SCA implementations will support Apache Axis 2 web services as a binding option. A useful interoperability test is to pass the schema from "series 1" from client to service and back to ensure that all marshalling and conversion operations work in both directions. @@ -199, +211 @@ Java Client - Java SCA/proxy - Axis Java Client - Axis C/C++ Server - C++ SCA/skeleton - C++ service - == Series 5 - SDO Serialization == + == Test 9 - SDO Serialization == For example, for use when the SDO data object graph is serialised into a session. || '''Feature''' || '''Schema''' || '''Java M1''' || '''C++ SVN''' || '''PHP R1.0.1''' || '''Note''' || || || interop1.xsd || ? || Not supported directly, Can use XMLHelper/XSDHelper separately. Already tested above || Supported via Serialize but PHP specific format uses C++ XMLHelper/XSDHelper under the covers || || - == SCA == - === Feature Comparison === - === General Observations === - *Java - *C++ - *PHP - == Attachments == [[AttachInfo]] --------------------------------------------------------------------- To unsubscribe, e-mail: [EMAIL PROTECTED] For additional commands, e-mail: [EMAIL PROTECTED]
