W dniu czw, 09.11.2017 o godzinie 23∶03 +0000, użytkownik Samuel Bernardo napisał: > Hi, > > I send this email to know the devs opinion about Gentoo integration with > Open Build Service[1]. > > When creating specialized images and using an automated process for > testing before deployment, I think that Open Build Service would be > useful. It already support all major binary based distros and I think > that Gentoo could be in there also. > > There is also a subforum with some interesting posts[2], where was > mentioned some references for Gentoo@OBS. > > I reviewed catalyst scripts and Gentoo workflow when creating the > package repository, and I think that it could be integrated in OBS. The > advantage is about creating repositories of binary packages from Gentoo > that would be used to deploy containers or VMs. This way, updates could > be applied to the images. OBS will be responsible to compile all images > that would be associated with their own created binary repository. > > To use the binary repository in Gentoo is suggested to use a nfs share > for portage/packages directory[3], but it would be a smoother > integration if emerge gets the packages directly from an url. > > You can ask, but for that why not using a binary disto? Well they're not > Gentoo... What I mean with this is that all the Gentoo tools, portage > architecture and the ebuild format that allows for excellent source > package definition (EAPI), turn it unique. Also the freedom associated > with Gentoo distribution that, with less effort than the others, allows > for the creation of new distros. Cross compiling tools are also amazing. > > So why shouldn't I wish to use Gentoo always? > > Well it don't need to be OBS, but since this opensource project have > some nice ideas, why not starting from there?
You've put a lot of theory in here but not really a single sentence on what needs to be done. I'm aware that some people used to be working on adding some OBS ebuilds to Gentoo but I've no clue about their goal. Long story short, if it requires changes to the ebuild format, then you have to list them and convince us. If it doesn't, then you are free to play with OBS any way you like. > > Best, > > Samuel > > [1] http://openbuildservice.org/ > > [2] https://forums.gentoo.org/viewtopic-p-7829060.html > > [3] https://wiki.gentoo.org/wiki/Binary_package_guide > > -- Best regards, Michał Górny
