https://agupubs.onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1029/2025EF007303

*Authors: *B. H. Redmond Roche, I. Hernandez-Galindo, A. Määttänen, J. C.
Moore, O. Boucher, B. M. Dollner, A. Duffey, B. Gasparini, J. Henneberger,
A. N. Koyun, D. McGrath, I. Steinke, J. Vinders, D. Visioni, P. J. Irvine

*23 May 2026*

https://doi.org/10.1029/2025EF007303

*Abstract*
Proposed solar radiation modification (SRM) field experiments are receiving
growing scientific and policy attention, with several localized experiments
having occurred or under development. While they may be critical for
improving technical understanding and reducing uncertainties, SRM field
experiments remain controversial and inadequately captured under current
legal, ethical, and political frameworks, which often rely on binary
“small-scale” or “large-scale” distinctions. In practice, SRM field
experiments may vary widely in scale, geography, materials, scientific
purpose, and environmental impacts, making uniform governance approaches
impractical. Here, we develop a typology of plausible, scientifically
motivated SRM field experiments across three leading approaches:
stratospheric aerosol injection (SAI), marine cloud brightening (MCB), and
cirrus and mixed-phase cloud thinning (CCT/MCT). We identify six SAI, five
MCB, and three CCT/MCT experiments across a range of scales, assessing
their interaction with existing environmental and legal frameworks,
particularly within the EU. The study also addresses governance challenges
such as scale perception and stakeholder legitimacy, and highlights
procedural tools, including exit ramps and transparency requirements. We
introduce a phase-based typology of plausible SRM field experiments:
near-phase (technically and regulatorily feasible), intermediate-phase
(technically feasible but likely to cross regulatory thresholds), and
distant-phase (plausible but requiring comprehensive review and new
governance mechanisms). The intermediate-phase highlights that SRM research
cannot be reduced to a small-/large-scale binary: many plausible
experiments occupy a gray zone where scientific value is high, but
governance remains underdeveloped. Recognizing this distinction may help
prioritize governance, guide proportionate regulation, and ensure field
experiments are evaluated by intent and their regulatory implications.

*Plain Language Summary*
Solar radiation modification (SRM) refers to a proposed set of methods for
cooling the planet by adding small particles to the atmosphere. This study
examines the three main approaches: stratospheric aerosol injection (SAI),
marine cloud brightening (MCB), and cirrus and mixed-phase cloud thinning
(CCT/MCT). SAI and MCB work by reflecting some sunlight back into space,
while CCT/MCT aim to reduce the heat-trapping effect of clouds. SRM field
experiments are important for improving scientific understanding of how
these methods work in practice. To explore what such experiments could look
like, we convened an expert workshop and identified six SAI, five MCB, and
three CCT/MCT experiments that would be scientifically useful and could
plausibly be undertaken. We also considered the challenges that previous
field experiments had experienced. From these defined experiments, we
developed a phase-based classification: near-term activities that are
technically and legally feasible, intermediate activities that may cross
regulatory thresholds and raise societal concerns, and distant activities
that would require new international governance. Our analysis shows that
existing laws could already be applied to some experiments and highlights
areas where additional rules are required. This helps create a common
language for researchers and policymakers to discuss SRM responsibly.

*Source: AGU*

-- 
You received this message because you are subscribed to the Google Groups 
"geoengineering" group.
To unsubscribe from this group and stop receiving emails from it, send an email 
to [email protected].
To view this discussion visit 
https://groups.google.com/d/msgid/geoengineering/CAHJsh9_cLH_agbytc%3DWmk1NZEeyjkyhWcPxUSs6esnMXMjKNbA%40mail.gmail.com.

Reply via email to