https://philarchive.org/rec/DESEHA-2

*Authors: *C. Tyler DesRoches, Joan McGregor & Stylianos Syropoulos

*08 June 2026*

*Abstract*
Current climate trajectories are alarming, with rising global temperatures,
extreme weather events, and looming tipping points threatening ecosystems
and human communities alike (Marlon et al. 2025; Wolf et al. 2025; NASA
2025). The prospect of geoengineering the Earth—the deliberate, large-scale
intervention in Earth’s climate system to help mitigate the negative
impacts associated with climate change—forces us to confront more than just
scientific and technological questions. It challenges us to examine
questions about our character. What should be said about the character of
those who would geoengineer the Earth? While the public discourse on
geoengineering has tended to emphasize the technological risks associated
with geoengineering, this article examines geoengineering through the lens
of environmental character, with a special focus on ecological humility. Is
geoengineering the Earth consistent with this environmental virtue? While
ecological humility is widely discussed among environmental virtue
ethicists, detailed accounts of this virtue are scarce. Matthew Pianalto
(2013) is the exception. Pianalto argues that ecological humility involves
several characteristic dispositions, such as acknowledging and accepting
that one is part of nature and dependent upon it. Moreover, the
ecologically humble person is open to learning from nature, appreciates the
intrinsic value of nature, and is motivated to adopt ways of living that
minimize impact on the natural world to preserve the intrinsic value of
nature. The ecologically arrogant, on the other hand, are characterized by
the impulse to dominate and control the nonhuman world (Whyte 2018; 2017).
For the ecologically arrogant, there are no limits on the human will. Human
beings are often assumed to stand atop the hierarchy of life on Earth, and
they are the only creatures truly worthy of moral consideration. Non-human
species and abiotic parts of the environment may be valuable, but only
insofar as they contribute to human well-being. This article builds on
Pianalto’s (2013) account of ecological humility and considers whether the
virtue is consistent with geoengineering. Our new account is grounded in
philosophy and recent advances in environmental psychology. On this
account, ecological humility is what Nancy Snow (1995) refers to as
existential virtue. The ecologically humble recognize and take seriously
the limitations and vulnerabilities associated with human existence,
especially in relation to non-human parts of nature. We will show that
psychologists have investigated components of ecological humility, linking
them to greater concern for, and action to ensure the protection of the
environment. Although psychologists have yet to measure ecological humility
directly, individuals who, for instance, espouse biospheric values also
experience awe, reverence, and care toward their ecological communities
(Wang et al., 2021; Yan & Jia, 2021), adopt non-anthropocentric beliefs
(Lou et al., 2025), and act to promote the flourishing of both human and
non-human members (Bouman et al., 2020; Wang et al., 2021). Importantly,
this includes intentional actions and omissions that confer benefits and
emphasize care over strict non-interference. Conceptually, we argue that
the virtue of ecological humility is linked to care via self-respect,
recognition of one’s own vulnerability, and attentiveness to interdependent
ecological relationships. Moreover, our account is empirically informed,
and action-guiding. By emphasizing care, vulnerability, and community
flourishing rather than minimizing one’s impact on nature, we argue that
ecological humility is consistent with human interventions that contribute
to ecological flourishing, which may include geoengineering the Earth.

*Source: Phil Archive *

-- 
You received this message because you are subscribed to the Google Groups 
"geoengineering" group.
To unsubscribe from this group and stop receiving emails from it, send an email 
to [email protected].
To view this discussion visit 
https://groups.google.com/d/msgid/geoengineering/CAHJsh9_u%2BOpu3j96QPPT59MBY0xOj5gZkpgJCn%2ByrQ6epj204w%40mail.gmail.com.

Reply via email to